Stop The Scrolling Header | Enable the Scrolling Header

Young Writers Society
News:  

Must Read: No Chat-Speak

Happy Thanksgiving!
Username:    Password:      Log me on automatically each visit    
Sunburnt Thirst
Sunburnt Thirst

by niccy_v in Advanced Critiques
Young Writers Society Forum Index » Other Fiction

This thread was created on June 27, 2008
Post new topic   Reply to topic
Digg It Del.icio.us


dawn with fox.

Topic ID: 32216
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
Medusa   View This User's Portfolio
Novelist

36
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 16
Joined: 12 Apr 2008
Posts: 266
Reviews: 36
Country: the face of consumerism
847 Points

PostPosted: Fri Jun 27, 2008 7:31 pm    Post subject: dawn with fox. Reply with quote

NOTE: Any poetry in this peice is a derivative of love sonnets from Elizabeth Barrett Browning, my aunt's favorite inspirational poet*

Dawn with Fox.

Marianne paces the dusty space between the neatly misshapen door and the giant gaping hole where the furnace should be. The air is cold, but in a still, obstinate way. The little cabin leaves little room for doubt: five hundred square feet, including one bathroom with a solidly rusted sink, one bedroom with a cracked window, and this space. She feels utterly, unequivocally bewildered. She’s at a loss as to what to do.

There’s the refrigerator, no food. Her canvases lie blank and bemused in the corner, wishing her ill. An easel is folded and hiding. Brushes, acrylics, oils. A cardboard box labeled TOM’S MARKET holds her complete collection of Shakespeare, Chaucer, Machiavelli. Her life sits in boxes. She grimaces.

Outside the cabin, her frosty pink Volkswagen sits in the snow, settling. Sinking. The air is so still she’s reluctant to move, reluctant to break the significant harmony, the perfect balance. She’s besotted with the air. She’ll never get any work done. Who is she kidding?

She drags two boxes to the bedroom, closes the door, stretches. Straightening up, she sees her reflection in the window, and grimaces a second time. Her stringy black hair, pale, translucent skin, thick red lips—all gawk back at her. She cowers, then looks past herself at an obscure spot of brown on the white blanket of snow.

It’s only there for a minute; she sees it, it sees her. She watches. Eyes widen. Tongues lap. The fox is gone, The fox sprits away on stealthy paws. Perhaps she’s not so alone after all. She feels triumphant.

She sets the canvases apart, rigs the easel, spreads the paints on the floor. The world beyong looks inviting. She really should go out.

She steps over a sketchbook, dog-eared and well-worn. She shoulders the door open, steps out, and embraces the cold. Her breath spirals into the misty air, and she hugs herself rather happily. The hills on either side are covered in silent, beautiful pines. The blue-peaked mountains glimmer from a distance, the sun hiding the shadowy shoulders.

The sky is a blue-gray canvas itself, silky smooth to perfection. Her feet sink in the snow as she waddles out to her car, locks it, and takes another step towards the forest. Crunch, crunch. The snow really isn’t as soft as she’d imagined.

She looks behind her, momentarily, and sees a pavement of pure marble, her footprints her footprints the only flaws to the surface. The air is quite still, but it sings a lullaby of fragments and lost words. There are screams of joy within the quiet breeze and she is shocked; awed..

She inches closer to her forest. Her doc martens start that soggy, temperamental feeling. Her eyes flicker over the stony branches, eerie shadows lacing white fingers. Crows caw. Birds shoot up from their nests. She eyes the fox on a ridge a few feet in.

It sits on its hind legs. Eyes wide, mouth wide. Mind wide. The lullaby is strong now, singing sweet music in a tuneless canto:

Guess who now holds thee?

Death, you said

but there the silver answer rang

not death, but love

And Marianne hears every word, disbelieving. The fox keeps his gaze steady. Unwavering. Sparkles belly-dance off the snow in swirls and cyclones. She tries not to move. Her stomach flutters.

A horn sounds. Marianne jumps, looks back at a small, black Jeep ravaging snow to meet her presence. Looking back, she sees the fox has gone into the shadows, hiding or just out of her line of vision. She waits. He stays hidden.

“Hello there!”

The voice is unfamiliar, unrecognizable. The sparkles dull into a low dim, still, and then stop all together. The sun feels strangely warm, hot almost. Marianne is uncomfortable. Her shoes sink.

“Careful,” the stranger warns, “the sun’s coming out and it wets the snow fast.”

He’s right. Her shoes are already sodden.

“My name is Luke,” the visitor shouts. He shuts off his engine, and his voice is suddenly very strong. Marianne looks into his face.

Luke is friendly, that much is obvious. If it isn’t for the ghosts lingering below his lids, and the light scruff creeping along his chin, Marianne would take him as one of those obnoxious neighborly people. Instead, she sees something that makes her feel more sociable, herself.

“Nice to meet you,” she says, not really insincere but not sincere either. “do you live close by?”

“No one lives close by,” Luke laughs, the air snatching his breath and hurling it to the sky. “You’re isolated, completely.”

Marianne’s neighborly grin is fading. “It’s what I want.” She gets this all the time. Questions, accusations. As if living in the middle of nowhere is out of the ordinary.

“I understand. I live a few miles out, on that ridge over there,” he points vaguely at a hill in the distance, and Marianne doesn’t even try to look. “I enjoy the solitude. It’s a perfect place to write, although I don’t write nearly as much as I should.”

“You’re a writer?” Marianne is intrigued. She feels momentarily connected to this Luke, as if they might have been friends a while back and are just now getting reacquainted.

“Of sorts,” he smiles wistfully. He stands, rocking slightly. Hands in pockets and a faraway look on his face.

“Want to come in?” Marianne asks catiously. “There’s not much,” she adds, regretfully. “I just moved.”

“I heard.” Luke’s all smiles. “I knew the couple who lived here. Practically everyone in this area of Prescott knows each other somehow or another.”

Marianne groans, inwardly. She understands this means she’ll be expected to make an effort at introducing herself. She walks to her cabin, Luke following a few steps behind.

“It’s a nice place,” he says, turning a one-eighty to get a good look at it. “The Brightons didn’t do much in the way of decoration.”

“I’m sure it’ll stay that way,” Marianne shoves her hands in her cardigan. “I’m way too busy procrastinating.”

Luke turns to the cavernous fireplace, and his eyes fall on the vacant canvases. He smiles. Marianne smiles. “I’m sure your art will grace these walls,” his arms loop in the air to indicate the bare cabin surrounding them, “it’d be a breath of fresh air; all that color.”

“Oh, I don’t know,” Marianne lingers behind him, careful to keep her eyes above the graceful curve of his shoulders, “I'm not the best with colors."

Luke turns; his expression is that of confusion. “The land isn’t grey. You should see it at sunset. Orange, crimson, gold...every color you’ve never seen.” He sounds defensive. Marianne holds her breath. “This land breathes color. At dawn it exhales the morning, and about noon it inhales the light and turns into every shade of blue and white. You just have to look deeper than the surface.”

“You really are a writer!” Marianne jests, nervously. Her hands twitch in her cardigan. Her hands twitch in her cardigan. Duh. I mean, just go ahead and state the obvious. Fool.

Luke shrugs, and that look of familiarity is void in his eyes. It’s replaced by another one she can’t decipher. He turns so they’re out of her line of vision. Cold. Vacant. Marianne sighs and wishes her mouth wasn’t quite as large as the hills behind them.

“Would you like something to drink? I have—“ then she remembers she has nothing. The empty refrigerator is silent and berating. She wants to kill herself.

Luke saves her from humiliation. “I’m fine, thanks.” He smiles, sheepishly unenthused. “I should be going, anyway,” he adds, taking a step to the door. “My typewriter is calling me. Thank you so much for your hospitality.” He doesn’t sound as grateful as he’s pretending.

For a moment, Marianne wants to reach out and take a hold on Luke’s arm, pulling him back. She imagines his surprised, then blissful look. He’ll bend over and say something comforting. Instead, she just sighs. She’s not a person for stepping out of the comfort zone. “Thank you.” Is what she says.

Luke nods, as if he’s just read her mind, opens the door, then half turns, surprising her. “You know,” he says, that jovial smile arising once more, “you’re welcome to come over anytime. It does get quite lonely up here.”

She smiles, sadly. She’ll make an apologetic and utterly pathetic excuse for herself. She’ll be busy, something about her car. The works. “Will do,” is what comes out of her mouth.

Then, Luke really is gone, and Marianne is left alone to further inflict self-wounds upon her metaphorical mind. She tries not to cry. She wishes for the dry, light heat of New Mexico. A bird chirps outside her window.

~~~

Later that night, Marianne lies awake on her mattress. Four blankets lie upon her, sweaty and thick. She shivers. Her muscles ache. Four hours of heavy lifting, and she’s finished the stage of arrival. She waits for it to settle in, but she’s too hopeless for hope.

She thinks about Luke. She thinks about a Fox. She turns. The light streaming in from the curtain-less window is really quite beautiful. It looks as if thousands of tiny wings float in a suspended beam of moonlight. She reaches out a tentative hand to touch it, and feels nothing. Her skin looks tickled-smooth and pale. The rest of her arm is shrouded in darkness.

The moon is bright and gorgeous. It looks swollen, fertile. A fully blossomed fruit ripe for the picking. She gazes until her eyes hurt. The hills are a giant mass of different shades of black. The snow is silvery, bathed in the spectacular light.

If she turns her head a certain angle towards the remote peaks, she can almost hear it again. The tuneless vibrato:

Guess who now holds thee?

Death, you said

but there the silver answer rang

not death, but love.

There is a sad, torpid movement in the air. She tries to form the words on the breath of air, and two things happen very quickly, very quietly: the air she breaths turns into a pane of mist on the glass window, and the fox reappears.

She almost loses it among the patches of black, black, and even darker black. It stands, legs spread apart. Teeth grin crookedly at her. The light covers it in a coat of glory.

Her heart catches in her throat. She knows she’s being watched, she’s seen. She feels as though she’s been caught red-handed. Guilty, the fox seems to say, Guilty, Guilty.

Guilty of what, she wonders. The fox blinks. She is overtaken by a sudden and overpowering urge to run out into the snow, barefoot, and catch the fox. She can almost feel the warm body. Fingers in fur. She slips out of bed, instantly regretting it. The floor freezes her toes.

Marianne runs lightly to the door, balancing on the balls of her feet. An oozing excitement reverberates through her body and up her spine. She sucks in her breath as she pulls the door open to face a hinterland of snow and ice. The cold shapes her form and escapes down the crevices of her nightgown, through the strands of her hair.

The fox is just within sight, panting beneath a giant pine. Its eyes glint with an untold magic. Marianne braces herself, and places one barefoot into the snow. At first, the powdery ground bites hard into her heels and stings her toes. She takes another step, then another. Soon she is walking, running, hopping along in the snow. Her feet turn numb, and then she feels no pain or cold.

The fox turns, but stays put. Marianne sees her legs racing, sees herself moving, but feels nothing. The fox tilts its head and she draws closer, agitated and out of breath. She stops within a foot. She watches her breath curl into the air and disappear, watches the fox, who is as silent as her drifting thoughts. It shifts slightly, drawing her from her frost-bitten reverie.

Our hands would touch—

“Excuse me?” Marianne speaks, feeling idiotic. “Is someone there?” She glances about in the forest. Why did she come here?

The fox shifts again, and Marianne can’t help but notice the hard glint in its eyes. She stares, unwilling to let herself look elsewhere. The voice starts up again, like a little record playing in the corner of her existence.

Our hands would touch for all the mountains

and heaven rolled between us at the end

“Who is that?” she shouts, anxiously. “I know you said something, I—“

The fox leaps at her, quite suddenly. Marianne closes her eyes against her shock, falls backwards. Wet fur brushes her cheek but nothing happens. She lies buried in snow. When she finds the courage to reopen her eyes, she is face to face with the fox. It is panting, its giant tongue vibrating in a rhythmic pattern; its heart is a little drum pounding mercilessly upon her skin. With one paw on her chest and one eye on the horizon, Marianne finally stays to listen.

Our hands would touch for all the mountains

and heaven rolled between us at the end

we should but vow the faster for the stars.

Marianne is not a believer of the supernatural. She has never been too religious, never been too superstitious. She agrees that what she does is a simple, down-to-earth kind of work, that she is not in need of any magical nonsensical nonsense. It comes to her as a surprise then, that she listens and accepts, without speaking, that this funny little creature is indeed a deep poet.

The fox has stopped breathing. It has taken her a few minutes to notice this subtle change of pace, the slowing of the heart and the pausing of the panting. She instinctively reaches out her forefinger and traces a little curl of white upon the fox’s throat. In a flash, the fox jumps up and races on a few feet. Stopping, he looks back. Marianne has the sensation that he is playing some sort of game with her.

She brings herself to an upward position, watching the fox from her elbows. It tilts its head in a familiar gesture, and she acknowledges him, standing. She believes she should feel silly, childish, following a fox in the wee hours of the morn. The sky is starting to fade like a pair of jeans, one blue lighter than the next.

The sun peeps out with one ray, then two. The fox is running up the slope, and she is following with steady feet. She has the feeling she is safe, secure. With the fox, she is not a part of nature, she is nature. The fox, the pine trees, the snow, the frozen air. They are her friends, they are her lovers.

Only an hour before sunrise, when the yellow star shakes it’s shyness off like a coat of armor, Marianne arrives, gasping for air with every inch of her life. The fox stands proudly on the edge of a valley more spectacular than any painting in any gallery. She inches towards him and sits on a glimmering black rock.

Grasping the sharp edges of the rock with the palms of her hands, she soaks in the world that had been hiding beyond the perimeters of her world. Below her, thousands of newborn plants are frosty in crystals more beautiful than any diamond. The ground is unmarked and undamaged. She breathes in as the sun makes its timid appearance. There is the fox, watching her with one eye and the plains with the other. There is the land that has filled the ditches in her heart with gold. There is the feeling that no matter where she strays, there will always be a place she can call home.

Our hands would touch for all the mountains

and heaven rolled between us in the end.

In loving memory of my aunt, Joellen Spiegel

1967-2007


_________________
Alice: If I had a world of my own, everything would be nonsense. Nothing would be what it is because everything would be what it isn't. And contrary-wise; what it is it wouldn't be, and what it wouldn't be, it would. You see?


Last edited by Medusa on Wed Jul 02, 2008 11:44 pm; edited 2 times in total
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address MSN Messenger
lluvialover   View This User's Portfolio
Junior Writer

21
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 17
Joined: 21 Mar 2008
Posts: 45
Reviews: 21
Country: USA
300 Points

PostPosted: Sat Jun 28, 2008 8:42 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

wow...simply beautiful. I did find a couple mistakes though.

Four hours of heavy lifting, and she’s finished the stage of arrived. She waits for settles in, but she’s too hopeless for hope.

Instead of 'arrived' it should be arriving. 'She waits for settles in' sounds strange, maybe 'she is waiting to settle in'?

I love your style, and the setting. It's in Arizona, right? I live in AZ, but never been to Prescot untill you described it here.
Will there be more, or is it finished? I think it can be either.
=)
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address MSN Messenger
Medusa   View This User's Portfolio
Novelist

36
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 16
Joined: 12 Apr 2008
Posts: 266
Reviews: 36
Country: the face of consumerism
847 Points

PostPosted: Sat Jun 28, 2008 8:49 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

lluvialover wrote:
wow...simply beautiful. I did find a couple mistakes though.

Four hours of heavy lifting, and she’s finished the stage of arrived. She waits for settles in, but she’s too hopeless for hope.

Instead of 'arrived' it should be arriving. 'She waits for settles in' sounds strange, maybe 'she is waiting to settle in'?

I love your style, and the setting. It's in Arizona, right? I live in AZ, but never been to Prescot untill you described it here.
Will there be more, or is it finished? I think it can be either.
=)


Actually, "settles in" and "arriving" are nouns here, (stages), not verbs.
Yes, it is in Arizona. My aunt and uncle lived there and I've gone up for camping a few times.
This is it, there won't be any more coming :p

--Medusa.

_________________
Alice: If I had a world of my own, everything would be nonsense. Nothing would be what it is because everything would be what it isn't. And contrary-wise; what it is it wouldn't be, and what it wouldn't be, it would. You see?
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address MSN Messenger
Clo   View This User's Portfolio
electronica dance queen
Master of the Forum

266
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 19
Joined: 13 Jun 2008
Posts: 1080
Reviews: 266
Country: in an Octopus's Garden
1097 Points

PostPosted: Sat Jun 28, 2008 9:56 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I've been meaning to review this, I'm glad it popped up in "Recent Additions" or I might have forgot. Very Happy

Quote:
Forty degrees in the sun. She really should go out.

I didn't understand what you meant when I first read this. Then I read it again and went "der", hitting myself in the head. But maybe you could phrase it a little more clearly, though that was pretty lame on my part.

Quote:
She looks behind her, momentarily, and sees a pavement of pure marble, her footprints embedded in the flawless nature

"pavement" and "pure marble" are really strange things to use to describe snow. I know you mention that the snow is not soft in the former paragraph, but I think you should reiterate it again in this paragraph and then turn this into a simile with "like" or "as" to clear up confusion.

Quote:
“My name is Luke,” Luke shouts.

The second Luke might sound better as a "he" but that's your preference.

Quote:
She sucks in her breath as she pulls the door open to face a hinterland of snow and ice

hinterland = winterland

Quote:
the fox jumps up and races on a few feet

On a few feet? That sounds awkward. Razz

Overall: this is a gorgeous story. Your descriptions of the landscape and the fox are beautiful, and I can just imagine it all. Having grown up in the north, in the country, in the middle of nowhere, I can appreciate this all quite a lot.

Your writing is sweet and mature. I love it, and this story gets a gold star. Very Happy

_________________
Need someone to toss the confetti at the ticker tape parade.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address Yahoo Messenger
Medusa   View This User's Portfolio
Novelist

36
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 16
Joined: 12 Apr 2008
Posts: 266
Reviews: 36
Country: the face of consumerism
847 Points

PostPosted: Sat Jun 28, 2008 11:40 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

hinterland:a region that is remote from cities or their cultural influence
and by "raced on", I mean went on...kept going...
Thanks though!

--Medusa.

_________________
Alice: If I had a world of my own, everything would be nonsense. Nothing would be what it is because everything would be what it isn't. And contrary-wise; what it is it wouldn't be, and what it wouldn't be, it would. You see?
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address MSN Messenger
yoha_ahoy   View This User's Portfolio
yoyo
Speaker of the Forum

379
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 18
Joined: 28 Aug 2005
Posts: 938
Reviews: 379
Country: living through my third eye
300 Points

PostPosted: Tue Jul 01, 2008 4:05 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Very good. I enjoyed your style as well. Just one big thing I noticed, being an artist myself...

“Oh, I don’t know,” Marianne lingers behind him, careful to keep her eyes above the graceful curve of his shoulders, “I do landscapes. It’ll all be grey and blah.”

Artists don't talk about their artwork like this. And being visual people, she certainly would've noticed more colors than the "grey blah." It just seems to me that you have the roles reversed as the visual artist and writer there. Good story though. I liked your imagery. THough I have to say, I did not understand the ending. It didn't make much sense to the rest of the story. But you do have a distinctive style here that I liked. Keep it up! Wink

~Yoyo Cool

_________________
@(^_^)@ Got YWS? Rick, FTW!

Visit my Site!!!: yoha_ahoy's website
Need something to critique? Check out Circus Pirates!
Need a critique instead? Then visit Yoyo's Crit Requests!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website AIM Address Yahoo Messenger MSN Messenger
Sapphire   View This User's Portfolio
Senior Writer

140
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 19
Joined: 23 May 2008
Posts: 233
Reviews: 140

350 Points

PostPosted: Wed Jul 02, 2008 3:03 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Sorry for all the quotations following, but it was unnecessary to quote the whole story and this was the easiest way of nit-picking!

Quote:
There’s the refrigerator, no food. Her canvases lie blank and bemused in the corner, wishing her ill. An easel is folded and hiding. Brushes, acrylic maybe use plural here too?, oils. A cardboard box labeled TOM’S MARKET holds her complete collection of Shakespeare, Chaucer, Machiavelli. Her life sits in boxes. - Like this. She grimaces.


Quote:
She steps over a sketchbook, dog-eared and well-worn. Hyphen in ‘well-worn’ too?


Quote:
She inches closer to her forest. Her dock martens start that soggy, temperamental feeling.


Quote:
A horn sounds. Marianne jumps, looks back at a small, black Jeep ravaging snow to meet her presence. Looking back, she sees the fox is ’has’ sounds better gone into the shadows, hiding or just out of her line of vision. She waits. He stays hidden.


Quote:
The voice is unfamiliar, unrecognizable. The sparkles dull into a low dim, stills, and then stops all together. If this sentence is still about the sparkles, the verbs need to be singular.


Quote:
Luke is friendly, that much is obvious. If it isn't wasn’t (I think!) for the ghosts lingering below his lids, and the light scruff creeping along his chin, Marianne would take him as one of those obnoxious neighborly people. Instead, she sees something that makes her feel more sociable, herself.

“Nice to meet you,” she says, not really insincere but not sincere either. “Do you live close by?”
“No one lives close by,” Luke laughs, the air snatching his breath and hurling it to the sky. “You’re isolated, completely.”

Marianne’s neighborly grin is fading. “It’s what I want.” She gets this all the time. Questions, accusations. As if living in the middle of the nowhere is out of the ordinary.


Quote:
“You’re a writer?” Marianne is taken back. She feels momentarily connected to this Luke, as if they might have been friends a while back and are just now getting reacquainted. Like this.


Quote:
“I heard.” Luke’s all smiles. “I knew the couple who lived here. Practically everyone in this area of Prescott knows each other somehow (no space) or another.”


Quote:
“I’m sure it’ll stay that way,” Marianne shoves her hands in her cardigan. “I’m way too busy procrastinating.” Ha!

Luke turns to the cavernous fireplace, and his eyes fall on the vacant canvases. He smiles. Marianne smiles. “I’m sure your art will grace these walls.His arms loop in the air to indicate the bare cabin surrounding them.It’d be a breath of fresh air; all that color.”

“Oh, I don’t know.” Marianne lingers behind him, careful to keep her eyes above the graceful curve of his shoulders. “I do landscapes. It’ll all be grey and blah.”

Luke turns; his expression is that of confusion. “The land isn’t grey. You should see it at sunset. Orange, crimson, gold... every color you’ve never seen.” He sounds defensive. Marianne holds her breath. “This land breathes of color. At dawn it exhales the morning, and about noon it inhales the light and turns into every shade of blue and white. You just have to look deeper than the surface.” I can see what yoha_ahoy means about the writer/artist roles here.


Quote:
Instead, she just sighs. She’s not a person for stepping out of the comfort zone. “Thank you,” is what she says. Changed slightly because capital letter looked strange.


Quote:
She’ll make an apologetic and utterly pathetic excuse for herself. She’ll be busy, something about her car. The works. “Will do.” is what comes out of her mouth. Odd punctuation, like before. Maybe swap full stop for a comma?


Quote:
Later that night, Marianne lies awake on her mattress. Four blankets lie upon her, sweaty and thick. She shivers. Her muscles ache. Four hours of heavy lifting, and she’s finished the stage of arrived. She waits for settles in, but she’s too hopeless for hope. I read the previous reviews and think these would be clearer as stages if they were in quotation marks.


Quote:
The moon is bright and gorgeous. It looks swollen, fertile. A fully blossomed fruit ripe for the picking. She gazes until her eyes hurt. The hills are a giant mass of different shades of black. The snow is silvery, bathed in the spectacular light.


Quote:
There is a sad, torpid movement in the air. She thinks of skulls, piled in a place her feet will never lie on. I don't understand the idea here. She tries to form the words on the breath of air, and two things happen very quickly, very quietly: the air she breaths turns into a pane of mist on the glass window, and the fox reappears.

She almost loses it among the patches of black, black, and even darker black. It stands, legs spread apart. Teeth grin crookedly at her. The light covers it in a coat of glory. Like the metaphor.

Her heart catches in her throat. She knows she’s being watched, she’s seen. She feels as though she’s been caught red-handed. Guilty, the fox seems to say, Guilty, Guilty. Maybe italicise ‘guilty’?

Guilty of what, she wonders. Again, maybe italicise her thought? The fox blinks. She is overtaken by a sudden and overpowering urge to run out into the snow, barefoot, and catch the fox. She can almost feel the warm body. Fingers in fur. She slips out of bed, instantly regretting it. The floor freezes her toes. Does she regret it because the floor is freezing? If so, you could use a semicolon to separate the sentences.


Quote:
The fox turns, but stays put. Marianne sees her legs racing, sees herself moving, but feels nothing. The fox tilts its head and she draws closer, agitated and out of breath. She stops within a foot. She watches her breath curl into the air and disappear, don’t like this comma but I’m unsure what it would be replaced by watches the fox, who is as silent as her drifting thoughts. It shifts slightly, drawing her from her frost-bitten reverie.


Quote:
It comes to her as a surprise, then, that she listens and accepts, without speaking, that this funny little creature is indeed a deep poet.

The fox has stopped breathing. It has taken her a few minutes to notice this subtle change of pace, the slowing of the heart and the pausing of the panting. She instinctively reaches out her forefinger and traces a little curl of white upon the fox’s throat. In a flash, the fox jumps up and races on a few feet. Stopping, he looks back. Marianne has the sensation that he is playing some sort of game with her.

She brings herself to an upward position, watching the fox from her elbows. It tilts its head in a familiar gesture, and she acknowledges him, standing. She believes she should feel silly, childish, following a fox in the wee hours of the morn. The sky is starting to fade like a pair of jeans, one blue lighter than the next. Nice simile.

The sun peeps out with one ray, then two. The fox is running up the slope, and she is following with steady feet. She has the feeling she is safe, secure. With the fox, she is not a part of nature, she is nature. The fox, the pine trees, the snow, the frozen air… they are her friends, they are her lovers. Changed punctuation slightly.


So enough of grammar! Allow me to make some general comments.

The first thing I have to say about this piece is how unique it is. I've never read anything like it and I just think the whole idea behind the story is wonderful.

I really loved the ending. I actually think it was stronger than your introduction, but then that often happens because, naturally, we have to set up the story at the beginning. I felt 'She feels utterly, unequivocally bewildered. She’s at a loss as to what to do' was 'telling' the reader a little too much. Her pacing is one good way of 'showing' instead.

Your vocabulary and power to describe are your strengths. I thought the piece was distinctive and very moving and, to be honest, aside from the punctuation and little things that I picked out in the quotations above, I can't really criticise anything.

Excellent. Smile

_________________
Click for critiques Smile

Dancing through life down at the Ozdust, if only because dust is what we come to – Wicked the Musical
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Medusa   View This User's Portfolio
Novelist

36
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 16
Joined: 12 Apr 2008
Posts: 266
Reviews: 36
Country: the face of consumerism
847 Points

PostPosted: Wed Jul 02, 2008 6:42 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Thanks! I made some changes, and I hope it's more accurate now.

--Medusa.

_________________
Alice: If I had a world of my own, everything would be nonsense. Nothing would be what it is because everything would be what it isn't. And contrary-wise; what it is it wouldn't be, and what it wouldn't be, it would. You see?
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address MSN Messenger
Kitty15   View This User's Portfolio
The Protector of the Prophecy
Writer of Legend

1324
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 18
Joined: 15 May 2007
Posts: 5370
Reviews: 1324
Country: England
1394 Points

PostPosted: Wed Jul 02, 2008 10:16 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Quote:
Dawn with Fox.
[This is a strange way to phrase your title. It makes me think Dawn is a person at first and I suppose that will be proved right or wrong as I read so I might edit this comment later but for now, I'd suggest Fox at Dawn or Dawn Fox.]
Quote:
Her frosty pink Volkswagen sits in the snow, settling. Sinking. The air is so still she’s reluctant to move, reluctant to break the significant harmony, the perfect balance. She’s besotted with the air. She’ll never get any work done. Who is she kidding?
[The transaction between the description of the room and her car outside needs to be smoother. Does she glance out the window at it? Or maybe even just say 'Outside the cabin' or something.]
Quote:
It’s only there for a minute; she sees it, it sees her. She watches. Eyes widen. Tongues lap. The fox is gone, half a nanosecond later. [This feels strange against the beautiful, natural imagery. Nanosecond sounds science fiction. It sounds out of place here. Maybe 'Tongues lap. The fox sprints away on stealthy paws.' or anything that's pretty and descriptive really. Something that doesn't break the lovely tone of this piece.] Perhaps she’s not so alone after all. She feels triumphant.

Quote:
She sets the canvases apart, rigs the easel, spreads the paints on the floor. Forty degrees in the sun. She really should go out.
[I agree that this doesn't quite work. It makes sense but the reader does have to stop and think about it a moment to be sure they have the right meaning. I'd suggest re-phrasing.]
Quote:
She steps over a sketchbook, dog-eared and well-worn. She thumps the door for good measure, [Uh... what? She thumps the door? Just for good measure? This sounds... odd. Maybe 'She shoulders the door open...' or 'She pushes the door hard...'] steps out, and embraces the cold. Her lips turn a darker shade of red [Just from standing out for a minute? No they don't. I've been in some real cold places, skiing in Italy most recently, and it takes a good while for the cold to start having an affect on your appearance, for your skin to pale and your lips to swell. Maybe 'Her breath spirals in the air' or something else. The cold has many immediately visible effects. Also, what is she wearing? Call me curious but I'd love you to describe how she's dressed.], and she hugs herself rather happily. The hills on either side are covered in silent, beautiful pines. The blue-peaked mountains glimmer from a distance, the sun hiding behind its [You can't use a plural form and then a singular. I'd suggest changing 'behind its' to behind the.] shadowy shoulders.

Quote:
The sky is a blue-gray canvas itself, silky smooth to perfection. Her feet sink in the snow as she waddles out to her car, locks it, and takes another step towards the forest. Crunch, crunch. The snow really isn’t as soft as she’d imagined.
[Why not move that earlier paragraph about the car to here. You'd need to edit a little but it would fit here much better.]
Quote:
She looks behind her, momentarily, and sees a pavement of pure marble, her footprints embedded in the flawless nature. [This sounds a little awkward. Maybe '...pure marble, her footprints the only flaws to the surface.'] The air is quite still, but it sings a lullaby of fragments and lost words. There are screams of joy within the quiet breeze and she is shockingly awed. [Shockingly awed doesn't quite work. Maybe '...and she is shocked; awed.' I know the meaning isn't quite the same but it runs more smoothly and fits your tone of narrative better.]

Quote:
“My name is Luke,” Luke [I agree that this needs to be he or the man or the visitor. That latter sounds quite nice.] shouts. He shuts off his engine, and his voice is suddenly very strong. Marianne looks at [I'd suggest into rather than at.] his face.

Quote:
“No one lives close by,” Luke laughs, the air snatching his breath and hurling it to the sky. “you’re [Should be 'You're' with a capital.] isolated, completely.”

Quote:
“You’re a writer?” Marianne is taken back. [The phrase it 'taken aback' but it doesn't really fit anyway. I think that's my largest criticism of this piece so far. You have some gorgeous imagery and your tone is mostly very lilting, very smooth but then you throw these colloquial phrases in and they cut through and break that tone. I'd suggest 'Marianne is intrigued' and it would fit with your next line better too. It's a much more positive reaction. Or if you want to keep the surprise there, maybe, 'Marianne is startled'.] She feels momentarily connected to this Luke, as if they might have been friends a while back and are just now getting reacquainted.

Quote:
“Of sorts,” he smiles wistfully. He stands, rocking slightly. Hands in pockets. A faraway look.
[We all know what you mean but it would be smoother to say 'A faraway look on his face.' just to avoid being fragmented all the time. It sounds lovely in places but don't over-use the technique.]
Quote:
“Want to come in?” Marianne mentally slaps herself. [Another phrase that doesn't fit with the lovely scene you've given us...] “There’s not much,” she adds, regretfully. “I just moved.”

Quote:
“Oh, I don’t know,” Marianne lingers behind him, careful to keep her eyes above the graceful curve of his shoulders, “I do landscapes. It’ll all be grey and blah.”
[My sister's an artist. She'd be strangling your character right now. Seriously. My sister's about the most humble, pessimistic perfectionist I know but even she wouldn't say that about her worst piece of work. Maybe 'I paint in grey scale' or something.]
Quote:
“You really are a writer!” Marianne jests, nervously. Her hands twitch in her cardigan. She mentally slaps herself once more.
[Again that phrase. Maybe it's just me who doesn't like it but to me it says 'modern writer' as awfully stereotypical as that and it says 'dramatic teen book' it says underdeveloped characters. Your reader should be able to tell when she's 'mentally slapping herself' as you put it. Use italics to show her thoughts if you must but your reader should be starting to get acquainted with your character. They should understand that she's nervous and she's not doing well, in fact she's very awkward in these social situation. Maybe 'Her hands twitch in her cardigan. Duh. I mean, just go ahead and state the obvious. Fool.' but she's your character so I don't know. But a few thoughts from her will convey much more personality than a silly phrase.]
Quote:
She smiles, sadly. She’ll make an apologetic and utterly pathetic excuse for herself. She’ll be busy, something about her car. The works. “Will do.” [Comma rather than full stop.] is what comes out of her mouth.

Quote:
Later that night, Marianne lies awake on her mattress. Four blankets lie upon her, sweaty and thick. She shivers. Her muscles ache. Four hours of heavy lifting, and she’s finished the stage of arrived. [Okay so it works but it doesn't sound good, you know? It sounds awkward. I'd suggest '...the stage of arrival.'] She waits for settles in, [Again, awkward! Maybe 'She waits for it to settle in...'] but she’s too hopeless for hope.

Quote:
The sun peeps out with one ray, than then two. The fox is running up the slope, and she is following with steady feet. She has the feeling she is safe, secure. With the fox, she is not a part of nature, she is nature. The fox, the pine trees, the snow, the frozen air. They are her friends, they are her lovers.

Overall.
This hasn't been easy to critique and I don't have much more for you: just general comments. I like the tone of this and you have some lovely description but as a piece of writing, a piece of substance, I found it a little ordinary and without plot. The inclusion of the poetry is nice and the sentiment is lovely, the idea that another person might reach out beyond the grave but there's no plot to it. There's no hint of a reason for the move other than a quest for solitude but what's the history behind that? It would be better if you threaded your character's past into it if you told us more of her and this feels unfinished. There's no real ending. No conclusion as to who this magical fox is, as to what will happen between her and Luke. There's no past and there's no hint of a future, only the present and that doesn't create a developed story. But it has potential. You have a lovely style of writing and it flowed smoothly in most places and Luke is an engaging character (much more so than Marianne) but I think the plot needs more work. Hope this helps a little,

Heather xx

_________________
Lest hope corrupt your foolish heart,
quick cast her out and let depart
the acrid whims of angel's wings
which clutch at twisted puppet strings.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message MSN Messenger
Medusa   View This User's Portfolio
Novelist

36
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 16
Joined: 12 Apr 2008
Posts: 266
Reviews: 36
Country: the face of consumerism
847 Points

PostPosted: Wed Jul 02, 2008 11:45 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Thank you so much, Kitty. Your crit was extremely helpful. I re-edited my peice, and changed some things, and I'm considering adding plot to make it...make more sense, or something...but thanks!

--Medusa.

_________________
Alice: If I had a world of my own, everything would be nonsense. Nothing would be what it is because everything would be what it isn't. And contrary-wise; what it is it wouldn't be, and what it wouldn't be, it would. You see?
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address MSN Messenger
BigBadBear   View This User's Portfolio
Pokémon! Gotta catch 'em all!
Master of the Forum

615
Gender: Gender:Male
Age: 15
Joined: 07 Oct 2007
Posts: 1720
Reviews: 615
Country: USA
937 Points

PostPosted: Sun Jul 06, 2008 10:53 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Medusa,


First of all, it was a very good story… for the most part. Second of all… what?

First: I liked the first half of the story a lot more than the second half. I know that this was supposed to be very dramatic and vague and meaningful, but the first half was my kind of a story. Ever since Luke came into the picture, everything suddenly started to make sense. I really liked that you made him a writer. It makes him a lot (for me, and YWS anyway) to relate to him. XD His words were a bit… different? Have you ever talked to a real life author? Do they really speak like that? No… I don’t. I speak like any average teen. I don’t use deep metaphors in my speech. Luke might, but it’s not very realistic.

Marianne is also a different character. I’m not quite sure what to make of her. At the beginning she seems all depressed and down… and by the end she’s chasing foxes? Does this have a deeper, metaphorical meaning? I sure hope so, because right now, this doesn’t make any sense at all.

I was kind of hoping that this would turn out to be a romance. It didn’t. Where did Luke go? He needs to have a bigger part in this story. There’s only three characters. Marianne, Luke and the fox. One of the characters doesn’t even speak!

If I were you, I would try to focus a bit more on where Luke shows up. He’s only there for about a page. We need to know more about Marianne to feel what she feels, and an excellent way to get characterization out is through dialog.

Okay. So I don’t want to be rude or anything, but this isn’t my favorite piece I’ve ever read. I’ve never been too great with metaphorical stories. That’s why I rarely do poetry. Too much to think about.

I’ve also provided a line-by-line critique in the attachment below. Thank you for posting in my Will Review for Food thread!

-Jared


Dawn with Fox.doc
 Description:

Download
 Filename:  Dawn with Fox.doc
 Filesize:  41.5 KB
 Downloaded:  21 Time(s)


_________________
Read The Novel House here!!

Enter the YWS Fanfic Contest Today!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website AIM Address MSN Messenger
Caligula's Launderette   View This User's Portfolio
the extemp queen
Master of the Forum

498
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 21
Joined: 13 Apr 2005
Posts: 2328
Reviews: 498
Country: how should I know, I don't even know where my socks are half the time?
300 Points

PostPosted: Tue Aug 19, 2008 5:28 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

'Lo there.

Look what I found, a review.

Razz

If you have any questions or have trouble reading my handwriting please tell me so.










GENDER ASSIGNMENT

You refer to the fox as both a he and an it. Was there a specific reason you did this? I think it would probably make things a much easier, possibly better read if you just picked one pronoun.

RAINBOW EFFECT

I love the multiple meanings and the many layers.

THE GLIDE PATH

I find it rather interesting and a cool, little idiosyncrasy that the prose gets noticeably smoother as soon as Luke shows up in the story. I'd kind of like to see more of Luke, though.

Very Happy


Ta,
Cal.

_________________
Fraser: Stop stealing the blanket.
[Diefenbaker whines]
Fraser: You're an Arctic Wolf, for God's sake.

Got YWS?
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website AIM Address MSN Messenger
Display posts from previous:   
This thread was created on June 27, 2008
Post new topic   Reply to topic
   Young Writers Society Forum Index » Other Fiction All times are GMT
Page 1 of 1

 
Jump to: