Stop The Scrolling Header | Enable the Scrolling Header

Young Writers Society
News:  

The Top 25!

Favorite part of writing?
Username:    Password:      Log me on automatically each visit    
Loves curse
Loves curse

by bryan in Dramatic Poetry
Young Writers Society Forum Index » Other Fiction

This thread was created on August 23, 2008
Post new topic   Reply to topic
Digg It Del.icio.us

Related Items
Possible Related Items Follow:
For Matty [Edited 3/21/08]
Out of Focus [Edited 8/29/08]

All There Is [Edited 8/30/08]

Topic ID: 34954
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
JFW1415   View This User's Portfolio
Team SPEW
Master of the Forum

367
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 14
Joined: 07 Jun 2007
Posts: 1288
Reviews: 367
Country: USA
1002 Points

PostPosted: Sat Aug 23, 2008 7:03 pm    Post subject: All There Is [Edited 8/30/08] Reply with quote

Note: Many of you will find this disturbing as pretty much the entire story is about self injurers. Also, about the cigarette - the guy with it is just smoking, but she's thinking about people who burn themselves.

This is for Kyte's Give Me Your Eyes contest.

Edit: this has been edited a lot. I decided to listen to you guys and take out the fact that the others cut. I had it that way because of the contest but I think this way works too.

Please read this version and let me know your thoughts!

All There Is

Look both ways, make sure no one's watching. Turn the knob – don't let it creak – slip inside. Strip to your underwear, look at your pale thigh, at the faded scars. You're legs are white beneath the fluorescent light, but they're covered with red lines, the mark of your Savior.

Reach under the sink – past the shampoo and the conditioner and the body wash – get one out. Take it out of its case, but don't put it on the stick – you're not shaving. Don't let it touch your fingers – too easy to slice, too easy to notice.

Bring it to your leg. Cool and loving, sharp and forgiving, pressed up against your skin. Slice. Tiny beads, dark red, a necklace for your leg. Wait – it'll sting soon.

Slice again and again until that's all there is.

-----

All around you are people. They push and shove you, pressing you into more who do the same. They're all rushing off to wherever they have to be – an empty apartment or an empty office – and don't look back at the person they forced out of the way.

You push through the crowd slowly, shying away from every touch, but it's impossible. Arms and legs are entangled and you find it repulsing but there's no way out so you push on for a while.

After twenty-three buildings pass you step off the sidewalk to catch your breath. The bodies are still pressing but only on one side, pushing you further into the road, past the parked cars and into the traffic. You turn so they're only pressing against your back, and you brace yourself.

If you get hit by a car and end up in a hospital the doctors will see It.

You were looking down at your shoes but now you look up. You raise your arm to signal a cab so you won't have to go back into the crowd. With your hand half-raised you stop, your eyes locked on a girl across the street who could be your twin despite the pitch black hair and tanned skin that doesn't match you at all. She's standing at the edge of the road in her baggy gray sweatshirt and she looks so lost and empty and just like you. Everyone else seems to be blind to her, but that's what makes you look.

She raises her arm to signal for a cab, and her fingers clutch her gray knit sleeve to hold it up. You don’t pay attention to what you're thinking and your thoughts go where you don't want them – to what could be under her sleeve: the same thing that's under your skirt.

The cab you had been signaling pulls up in front of you, blocking the spot the girl had been. You blink a few times, get out of your daze, then step inside.

-----

The cab's not as crowded as the road had been, but it smells. The man in front doesn't apologize for this. "The woman just before you had four kids and three cats," he says in explanation. You nod but don't say anything. It's not the smell of children or of cats that's bothering you.

"Do you like cats?" he asks after a moment, trying to break the silence. You don’t say anything, just continue looking out the window, hoping he'll be quiet.

"Miss?" the man asks again, and he lifts his eyes from the road to look at you through the rearview mirror he's turned in. Your hand automatically goes to you leg, presses against it, and you try not to wince.

He turns it in to watch – he's a freak – he's a spy – he wants to know your secret…

You turn the wince that slipped through into a smile, then look out the window. All the people on the street who are walking faster than you're moving, but you'd still rather be in here even with the smell. Every second you sit there costs you more and more money and you're wasting your time, but you'd rather be broke and late than be out there where everyone's so close.

The man reaches into the seat next to you, the one you can't see, and rummages around for a moment until he finds what he was looking for. "You mind?" he asks, holding up a carton of Camel cigarettes and an orange lighter.

You go to shake your head, no, you don't mind, but it's already shaking. Your whole body is shaking and you can't stop it so you try to make it look like you're in control, you're always in control.

You get your body under control but you can't make your mind listen. It shows you pictures of people putting a flame their skin and waiting, letting it burn away.

The lighter's not your Savior but you know it's someone's Savior and that scares you.

-----

You get out of that cab as fast as you can.

"Are you all right, Miss?" he asks when you tell him you want to get out. It's in the middle of the road but you're not moving so you nod and open the door.

"Hey, wait!" he says as you're halfway out the door, your purse flying along behind you. "That's fifteen ninety."

You stare at him for a moment, with his cigarette dangling from the corner of his mouth and his smoke filling up the cab. You shake your head, blink your eyes. He stares back at you expectantly, so you grab a few bills from your purse and shove them into his hands, pulling back quickly before the Savior can come near you.

-----

"Please, sit down," the woman says to you, gesturing to the chair in front of her desk. You stand at the doorway uncertainly, looking around the room, searching for any Saviors. You've seen too many ghosts of them today and you just want to get away from them all.

The office is huge. Behind the woman are two windows, wide open to reveal the sounds and smells and lights of New York. Along the walls are gleaming silver cabinets with white papers covered in ink overflowing from them. On her desk is a computer, keyboard, glass of water half drunk, and a nameplate.

No Saviors in sight.

You go over to the chair and sit down, perching on the edge. In your hands is your resume, covering your black pencil skirt – even more protection from people seeing It.

Her eyes land on your leg, and you have to breath in deep, remind yourself that she's looking at the papers, not what's underneath. She's smiling at you as you raise your arm, hand over the papers. You pull back, bring the glass with you. It crashes onto the desk, glass shattering, water flowing everywhere.

The Saviors had been hiding.

"Shoot!" she shouts, jumping up and raising her arms up. She starts shoving the bits of jagged glass into a pile, the water sloshing around in a puddle on the wood, and you just sit there, unsure of what to do.

"Uh, up there," the woman says, nodding her head towards a cabinet, her hands busy scraping together the remnants of her glass. "Paper towels, fourth row up – please hurry!" She's pulling away her keyboard and computer and patting down her skirt – all soaked in water – desperately.

You nod, rip your gaze away from the Saviors, stand up from your seat. You instantly ache for the comfort of the padded chair once more, the secure arms guarding you, but you push forward. You walk to the cabinets, search through the fourth drawer, take out the paper towels.

She reaches out for the paper towels the second you get back to the desk, pats her skirt and computer dry. "The trash, right over there," she says, nodding to her left. You look over, then walk over to grab it. Inside's a banana and a bunch of crumpled up paper and no Saviors, but she's going to put them in.

You tell her you have to go. She's in the middle of pushing the Saviors into the trash and she asks why, but you tell her you just remembered you had a family obligation – a lie. She sighs but tells you that's fine, that she has your resume, and that she'll call you if anything comes up.

You nod and walk out of the room and away from the Saviors.

-----

You don't take the cab home because you're afraid you'll get him again It's with him. It's not good and you want It gone but It's everywhere…

So you go through the crowd again. They push and shove and control you but at least you aren't confined anymore. You can slip into the road – no car's moving anyway – and leave for a minute when you run out of air.

One big breath in. It has to last for a long time so breathe slowly and don't waste it, only so much left…

You slip back into the crowd, hold your purse close to your body, let yourself be drawn closer to your apartment building.

You pull apart from the crowd as soon as you get there, gasping and wheezing for breath, your hands on your knees, head lowered. "Ma'am?" says the doorman, and you jerk your head up to see him. He's smiling down at you with one hand folded behind his back and the other holding open the door for you but it doesn't look real. He's too clean and press-cut and you wonder if he's actually there.

You straighten yourself and go to walk through the door, but you trip in the doorway, and your legs collapse and your arms go out to catch you, but you're not quick enough. His arm jerks out, and his flesh is warm and strong on yours.

You pull away from his hand then stand up, refusing his help. You don't want his hand on you for too long because it might leave a bruise and you're already marked up enough. You don't hit yourself and you don't want to look like you do.

You offer him a forced smile and slip through the doorway, straight to the elevator and up the seven flights to your apartment.

-----

You reach your floor. The wood echoes under your heels as you clip, clip, clip down the hall, past room 702, 704, 706, finally reaching your number.

The hall is empty, but you still shove the key into the door, slip inside, lock the door behind you. All fast – very fast – because someone could be watching. Someone's always watching.

But your apartment feels empty. The air's still and the room's quiet, but you still sneak into your bathroom because someone could be watching.

The door closes with a click behind you and you stand there, hands on either side of the porcelain sink, cold beneath your fingers. You stare at your reflection for seconds, minutes, hours, not recognizing the woman before you, not understanding how someone so broken could possibly be you.

You reach under the sink and take out your Savior of choice.

-----

The metal is cool and familiar in your hand as you bring it to your bare leg and prepare to redden the pale skin below the lines – the sets of three perfect lines – that you made yesterday.

Slice. Look down at the beads of blood peeking out of your skin, staining you leg red. Wait – it'll sting soon.

Slice again and again until that's all there is.


_________________
Man is least himself when he talks in his own person. Give him a mask, and he will tell you the truth. -Oscar Wilde

Join the CIA.

In response to hearing my new story idea: "Aunt April": Oookaaay. You are one sick little puppy aren't you?


Last edited by JFW1415 on Sat Aug 30, 2008 9:31 pm; edited 4 times in total
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address MSN Messenger
Conrad Rice   View This User's Portfolio
Clo's Girlfriend...You're Jealous.
Novelist

134
Gender: Gender:Male
Age: 18
Joined: 13 Apr 2008
Posts: 415
Reviews: 134
Country: The Ocean
433 Points

PostPosted: Sat Aug 23, 2008 7:37 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Well, this was an interesting piece to say the least. While I can't say that I understand self-injurers, I can honestly say that I have a lot more sympathy for them after reading this story. That being said, lets get to the critique.

You pulled off second person perspective here. I know you mentioned that you were writing a story like that, but I kind of wondered about it. Second person is kind of hard to do. Now that I can see the finished product, I can honestly say you made it work. Props to you on that. Smile

It took me a little bit to understand that when you talked about Saviors, you were talking about knives and other sharp things. You might need to hint at what you mean a little stronger, I don't know. Once I finally got what it was, it worked just fine, but for a little bit I was scratching my head in confusion.

It seems like you're missing something here that might connect readers to this concept a little stronger. Why does cutting work and nothing else does? I mean, there could be drugs, or simply smoking, or something like that which could possibly serve the same purpose. It's just a thought of mine, and the story works well without it, but it may do your story some good to explain that.

Well, all in all, this was a very good story. I always have a hard time finding things to critique in your stories, so I get all nitpicky and crap. Oh well, hope you do well in the contest. Kudos.

_________________
It'll all be k, everybody. It'll all be k.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
GryphonFledgling   View This User's Portfolio
It's elementary...
Speaker of the Forum

471
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 17
Joined: 30 Dec 2007
Posts: 811
Reviews: 471
Country: Baker Street
650 Points

PostPosted: Sat Aug 23, 2008 8:49 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Wow, I liked this a lot more than I thought I would. Despite your disclaimer at the top and my general lack of love for the "cutter" stories, I clicked on this. I figured the least I could do was tell you how horrible and angsty it was. (Bear with me, I'm in a grumpy mood...)

But this surprised me. It was still kind of angst-ridden, but at the same time, was strangely beautiful. You pulled off the second person (a devilishly hard perspective) masterfully. I didn't even realize that it was in the second person until about halfway through. No joke.

Very nice about the Saviors. I agree with Conrad though, that it takes a minute to get. Not that it is necessarily a bad thing. I understood by the end of the piece and the revelation was good. At first I almost though she was talking about well-meaning people (the cabbie seemed to be a nice enough guy) until she talks about the Saviors and the glass. Very nice and quite stylish, I must say.

My only real nitpick would be the one line of thought regarding the cabbie's turned mirror.

Quote:
He turns it in to watch the people he's a freak he's a spy he wants to know my secret…


It is the only instance of first person in the entire piece and it feels a little out of place, considering all the other internal dialogue and italics are in second person. I'd change it to second person as well, so that it flows a bit better with the rest.

Other than that, this was great. I don't get people who self-injure and I generally dislike stories about them, just because such a sensitive issue becomes a cliche and is handled poorly, but you have done a good job.

*thumbs up* Good luck in the contest!

~GryphonFledgling

_________________
Ink is the strongest drug, the deepest ocean, the longest journey and the strangest love. ~me

Jareth/Sarah shipper...

Kickin' butt and not stopping to take wordcount. NaNo 2008! Read my novel here!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Black Ghost   View This User's Portfolio
Life Is Sexually Transmitted
Speaker of the Forum

276
Gender: Gender:Male
Age: 17
Joined: 04 Feb 2006
Posts: 986
Reviews: 276
Country: The Edge of Inspiration
300 Points

PostPosted: Sun Aug 24, 2008 3:49 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Greetings! Here's your line by line. Very Happy

Quote:
Look both ways, make sure no one's watching.


Good opening line. It really establishes the whole tone and situation, and is a really great hook as well. The reader knows she's about to do something interesting, since she's making sure she's alone, so it's a great first line.

Quote:
Turn the knob – don't let it creak – slip inside. Strip to your underwear, look at your pale thigh, at the faded scars, white beneath the fluorescent light.


Good description, except I think it would sound better if you changed the last bit. See, you mention two objects (thigh and scars) and then go on to say that something is white beneath the light. I don't know if your referring to the scar, the thigh, or both. To improve clarity, I would do this:

Strip to your underwear, loot at your pale thigh, at the faded scars. They're white beneath the flourescent light.

Sounds better, no?

Quote:
Reach under the sink – past the shampoo and the conditioner and the body wash – get one out. Take it out of its case. Don't let it touch your fingers – too easy to slice, too easy to notice.


It took me couple of reads to understand what was happening here. I know you're trying to be ambigous and creepy, but it isn't immediately clear what's going on, the reader can get lost. I would fix this by being more specific of what she's reaching for. One of the keys to vivid writing is to be as specific with your nouns as possible. For example the term pit bull creates a sharper image than simply the word dog.

Now since you don't want to go right out and say what it is due to the way you have things set up, you should instead describe its features (sharp edge, metal surface, things of that nature) to improve clarity. There's nothing worse than losing your reader when you're in the middle of an intense scene, because then everything sort of deflates.

Quote:
Bring it to your leg. Cool and loving, sharp and forgiving, pressed up against your skin. Slice. Tiny beads, dark red, a necklace for your leg. Wait – it'll sting soon.


See, this is the type of description I was talking about. You're being vivid and clear without actually naming the object. Do this for the part above when she's looking for it, and you'll be fine. Also, your description of the blood is beautiful. It comes across very nicely and creates a very sharp image. Really, it's chill inducing. ^_^

Quote:
Slice again and again and again until that's all there is.


I have some qualms about this. There may be too many 'agains' for its own good. See, when writing you need to be as concise as possible, as if you're trying to stick your reader with a literary knife (sorry, couldn't resist). You seem to have that down so far, but not with this sentence. Repetition in this case does not add to the effect of the sentence, but instead makes it laborous to read. I would consider changing this to something shorter and with more punch.

Quote:
All around you are people.


Another good opening line. It sets the situation up again and is another great hook. But I also notice you're sticking with second person, which could be a problem. I mean, your reader isn't an Obssessive cutter, are they (hopefully not), so why would they want to be directly addressed as if they were this character? Some readers could be turned off by this, so I offer you caution.

Quote:
They're to your right and to your left and behind you and in front of you and everywhere. They push and shove and rush to get wherever they're going and don't turn back to look at the person who they forced out of the way, to look at you.


Remember how I talked about being specific? Why don't you describe the actual places that these people might be going (ex: their lonely cubicles) in order to be more vivid? You can also use this to your advantage by choosing words to add to the atmosphere and tone of the narrative.

Quote:
You push your way through the crowd slowly, shying away from every touch, but it's impossible. Limbs are entangled with limbs and you find it repulsing but there's no way out so you push on.


Again, be specific with your nouns. What limbs exactly? Legs, arms, fingers, shoulders, you get the idea. Give us as clear a picture as possible.

Quote:
You pull you the side to catch your breath.


What do you mean exactly when she pulls to the side? Does she lean against a brick wall, or use a railing for support as she catches her breat?

Quote:
The bodies are still pressing but only on one side, pushing you out into the road, out in front of the still traffic. You turn so they're only pressing against your back, and you brace yourself.


Just describe it as 'traffic', and take out the 'still'. The word traffic is sufficient to describe what's going on, and still traffic sounds weird, as if everything's frozen. :/ Also, I was a bit confused in this part. Is she in the street, or she on the extreme edge of the sidewalk or something? Try to make it a bit clearer.

Quote:
If you get hit by a car and end up in a hospital the doctors will see It.


If she gets hit by a car she might die. I think a few scars would be the least of her worries. Wink

Quote:
Across the road is a girl doing the same thing you are, in the same kind of clothes – a baggy, dreary colored sweatshirt, loose jeans, hair long and straggly.


How is she doing the same thing she is? You described the way she dressed, but you didn't elaborate on what she was doing that was similar. Making her way through the crowd, maybe? But everyone on the sidewalk is. I don't that's enough to catch her eye.

Quote:
Your eyes are drawn to her, at the girl who could be your twin despite the golden hair and the sea colored eyes that don't match you at all.


This sentence sound a little long. You want to flow, and this sentence doesn't I would split it up, maybe, or just shorten it, because it sounds as if it drags on.

Quote:
She raises her arm to signal for a cab, and her sleeve falls down. You see It and It's all you can think about as you slip back into the crowd with all the normal people and she slips into the cab and you go opposite ways.


Again, the second sentence is extremely long. You're trying to pack too much into a sentence, so try to break this one up into a couple of nice, smooth sentences. ^_^

Quote:
The cab's not as crowded as the road had been, but it smells. The man in front doesn't apologize for this. "The woman just before you had four kids and three cats," he says in explanation. You nod but don't say anything. It's not the smell of children or of cats that's bothering you.


Wha? I thought that the other girl got into the cab. Now we're in the cab? You should fix this, because in the paragraph above this you make it clear that we are still in the crowd and that someone else got in the cab.

Quote:
"Miss?" the man asks again, and he lifts his eyes from the road to look at you through the rearview mirror he's turned in. Your hand automatically goes to you leg, presses against it, and you force yourself not to wince.


Why did he say "Miss"? He doesn't apologize, explains quickly and then addresses her as if they were talking? It seems a little bit strange. I would expect just not to talk anymore, as if he was forced to give a quick explanation just so he could be silent again. Why don't you have him ask her a question, which would make the "Miss?" more plausible.

Quote:
He turns it in to watch the people he's a freak he's a spy he wants to know your secret…


I know this is happening in her mind, but that doesn't mean you can't have proper punctuation. You can capture her disoriented paranoid train of thought without making it into a run-on sentence. Play with it a bit, since it's not fun to read.

Quote:
You turn the grimace to a smile then look out the window at all the people on the street who are walking faster than you're moving, but you'd till rather be in here with the smell.


Again, this sentence seems long...maybe you can break it up like this?

You turn the grimace into a smile. Outside the window you can see all the people who are walking faster than you're moving, but you'd still rather be in here with the smell.

It's easier to read, and sounds better in my opinion.

Quote:
Every second you sit there costs you more and more money and you're wasting your time but you'd rather be broke and late than be out there where everyone's so close.


More longness. I think by now you get the picture by now on how you should fix them. And this isn't because I'm against long sentences. It's okay to have longer sentences, if they flow and have proper grammar, that is. The kind of long sentences you write almost seem linke run-ons, and you feel like you're stumbling through them as you read. I'm not sure if this is intended, but I would consider changing them if it's not.

Quote:
In front of you the reaches into the seat next to you, the seat in front of you, the one you can't see. "You mind?" he asks, holding up a carton of Camel cigarettes and an orange lighter.


Probably the most awkward sentence so far.

"In front of you he reaches into the seat next to you, the seat in front of you, the one you can't see.

Because of the repitition, this sentence is just plain bad. You could rephrase it so much more simply.

"He reaches into the seat next to him, the one you can't see."

^_^

Quote:
You go to shake your head, no, you don't mind, but it's already shaking. Your whole body is shaking and you can't stop it so you try to make it look like you're in control, you're always in control, you have to be in control…


I would change up the last bit like this, since it seems weird when you read it:

"Your whole body is shaking and you can't stop you try to make it look like you're in control, like your always in control. You have to be in control..."

Quote:
It's not your Savior but you know it's someone's Savior and that scares you.


Hm. Interesting train of thought you've got going here. Why exactly does it scare her that it's someone else's savior? If you could somehow elaborate on it a bit without jumping into some sort of exposition, taht would be awesome. I'm interested in seeing why she thinks like this.

Quote:
You get out of that cab as fast as you can.


Nothing bad about this line. It starts to pick up action again, which is good.

Quote:
"Are you all right, Miss?" he asks when you tell him you want to get out. It's in the middle of the road but you're not moving and you won't be for a long time so you nod and open the door.


Huh. It's interesting how you never actually make her speak (I assume it's due to the second person) and I think it's a nice touch, actually. Makes the reader feel attached and detached at once (if that makes sense).

Quote:
"Uh, Miss?" he asks as you're halfway out the door, your purse flying along behind you. "That's fifteen ninety."


Isn't this the billionth time he's said miss? Just have him demand the money and leave it at that.

Quote:
You stare at him for a moment, with his cigarette dangling from the corner of his mouth and his smoke filling up the cab then shake your head, blink your eyes. You grab a few bills from your purse and shove them into his hands, pulling back quickly back before the Savior can come near you.


Your first sentence is run-on. Break it up into two, please. The second sentence is awesome though, it really captures her emotions and state of mind. In fact, other the grammar issues I've mentioned, you do a fabulous job of portraying her as a very disturbed woman, and it never seems forced or anything.


Quote:
The office is huge. Behind the woman are two windows, wide open to reveal the sounds and smells and lights of New York. Along the walls are gleaming silver cabinets with white papers overflowing from them. On her desk in a computer, keyboard, glass half empty, and a nameplate with her name etched into it. No Saviors in sight.


Lovely description, except you're being redundant when you say "nameplate with her name sketched on it." You can just say nameplate, since it's obvious her name would be on it. Wink

Quote:
You go over to the chair and sit down, perching on the edge. In your hands is your resume, covering your black pencil skirt, even more protection from people seeing It.


Your second sentence is extremely awkward. Try this.

In your hands is your resume, covering your black pencil skirt. Even more protection from people seeing it.

Quote:
Her eyes land on your leg, and you have to breath in deep, remind yourself that she's looking at the papers, not underneath. She's smiling at you as you raise your arm, hand over the papers. You pull back, bring the glass with you. It crashes onto the desk, water overflows, glass shatters.


I really like this bit. It's very consistent with her character, and I love they way she's always self-concious about her thigh. But the last sentence seems slightly illogical. Wouldn't the glass break break first? And the water would really just splash onto the floor, since it has nothing to overflow from since the glass has shattered. Just something to consider clearing up.

Quote:
The Saviors had been hiding.


Back to the idea of "saviors" which I think is actually a pretty powerful metaphor that you've chosen. It also makes the whole thing a little less disturbing for some reason, but instead just makes it very dark, which in my opinion is better than disturbing. *shrugs*

Quote:
"Shit!" she yells, jumping up and raising her arms up. "Shit shit shit shit shit…" She starts shoving the bits of jagged glass into a pile, the water sloshing around in a puddle on the wood, and you just sit there, unsure of what to do.


Yeah, that's not very professional of her. I doubt if you were going to an interview the person would start shouting that repeatedly. In fact, you make her sound like some five year old... Please change it.

Quote:
"Uh, up there," the woman says, nodding her head towards a cabinet, her hands busy scraping together the remnants of her glass. "Paper towels, fourth row up – shit!"


She really is overeacting...it's just water.

Quote:
You nod, rip your gaze away from the Saviors, stand up from your seat. You instantly ache for the comfort of the padded chair once more, the secure arms guarding you, but you push forward and walk to the cabinets, search through the fourth drawer, take out the paper towels.


This is good. You always make sure to let her inner feelings come through at every moments, which is a good thing.

Quote:
As you turn to face the woman again, paper towels in hand, you see her hastily shoving the sharpest piece of glass into her pocket. She freezes – the towels fall to the floor – and the room becomes eerily silent.

Finally her mouth closes from the shock, and she withdraws her hand from her pocket. Her eyes flicker down to the paper towels at your feet, and you hastily bend down, pick them up, hand them to her.

"Thank… thank you," she says, not looking you in the eye as you set them on the desk, the bottom of every single layer becoming soaked through. "I'll give you a call if anything comes up."

You nod and walk out of the room.


So she's a cutter too? Um...why? Isn't that too much of a coincidence? The story is strong enough with just the one character being like that. But if suddenly everyone becomes a cutter, it's like "Um....no." I mean, what's the point of having someone else like her? Not that I'm saying there can't be more than one person who cuts themselves, but the way you have it makes it seem like too much of a coincidence to be really plausible. Just please consider toying with that if it's not completely necessary.


Quote:
You don't take the cab home because you're afraid you'll get Him again and He does It and It's not good and you want it gone gone gone gone gone…


The only time you capitalize "he" is if you're talking about God. So change those to lowercase. Also, this sentence isn't dramatic, it's a grammatical train wreck. Bad grammar does not, I repeat not, make your story more dramatic. Please fix this.

Quote:
So you go through the crowd again. They push and shove and control you but at least you aren't confined anymore. You can slip into the road – no car's moving anyway – and leave for a minute when you run out of air.


This is fine. Not really anything that needs changing, so yeah. Razz

Quote:
One big breath in. It has to last for a long time breathe slowly don't waste it only so much left…


Again, fix the grammar. You make her seem like a babbling idiot. Seriously.

Quote:
You slip back into the crowd, hold your purse close to your body, let yourself be drawn closer and closer the your apartment building.


One "closer" is sufficient.

Quote:
There's the door. Straight ahead.


You know, in relation to what comes after this, I think the narrative would flow better if you just deleted this line. My personal preference, you can keep it if you want.

Quote:
You pull apart from the crowd as soon as you get there, gasping and wheezing for breath, your hands on your knees, head lowered. "Miss?" says the doorman, and you jerk your head up to see him. He's smiling down at you with one hand folded behind his back and the other holding open the door for you but it doesn't look real. He's too clean and press-cut and you wonder if he's actually there.


Does everyone refer to her as "Miss?" Use some variety please, because it seems as if the cab driver is talking to her again. He can say "Ma'am", or maybe "Mrs. [insert name here]". Just don't use "miss" again. It's distracting.

Quote:
You straighten yourself and go to walk through the door, but you trip in the doorway, and your arms and legs and purse go flying everywhere. His arm jerks out to grab you, and his flesh is warm and strong on yours.


Saying her arms and legs were "flying everywhere" doesn't make much sense. Also, maybe you could specify by saying the contents of her purse flew everywhere. I would change the description, because the picture in my mind is of her limbs flying off of her. Confused

Quote:
You pull away from his hand and gather your legs and your arms and your purse, then stand up, refusing his help. His arm is still there, extended out for you to lean on, but it's the one that he had kept hidden.


Again, its as if you're describing her limbs as if they're detached from her. I get a picture of her going to pick up actualy arms and legs off the floor. It's weird, to say the least.

Quote:
It's purple and swollen and bloody and he hasn't been in a fight.


Now he's a self injurer? I know in your preface you said this story would be about self injurer, but I thought you meant just the one. To be honest, if I was reading this in a bookstore, I would think it's just ridiculous emo crap. I say this because this isn't that. It's a beautiful portrayal of a girl and her internal struggles. Please stop making everyone a cutter, because it's really taking away from your story. But remember, this is only my opinion, you can take it or leave it.

Quote:
You offer his a forced smile and slip through the doorway, straight to the elevator and up the seven flights to your apartment.


Typo. I think you meant "him" instead of "his".

Quote:
You reach your floor. The wood echoes under your heels as you clip, clip, clip down the hall, past room 702, 704, 706, finally reach your number.


Finally reaching your number.

Quote:
But your apartment feels empty and you drop your purse on the couch, the empty couch, and walk through the empty living room to the empty hall and into the empty bathroom.


What's the point of describing it as an empty couch? And the repitition of empty for everything else it weak. I know you're capable of better description than that. Smile

Quote:
The door closes with a click behind you and you stand there, hands on either side of the porcelain sink, the material cold beneath your finger. You stare at your reflection for seconds, minutes, hours, days, not recognizing the woman before you, not understanding how someone so broken could possibly be you.


I thought this paragraph was great. Especially the part when you're describing her looking at her self in the mirror. Really, really good. ^_^

Quote:
You reach under the sink and take out your Savior of choice.


Also an excellent line. Never change it.

Quote:
You don't care so much this time because you know you're not alone and this isn't a bad way to escape everything because there wouldn't be so many people doing It if it were.


This is a point of lameness, I'm afraid. There is no way she'd have so many coincidences in one day, and then go home to cut herself feeling justified. I'm not sure how you could do away with this unless you changed the fact that she came across more cutters (which, like I said, is not plausible in the least).

Quote:
The metal is cool and familiar in your hand as you bring it to your bare leg and prepare to redden the pale skin below the lines – the sets of three perfect lines – that you made yesterday.

Everyone does it. Everyone does it. Everyone does it.

You slice. You slice again and again and again until that's all there is.


So basically, the summary of this thing would be that a cutter went about her day, feeling all bad, but noticed that everyone cuts themselves, so ends up feeling better about it and goes home to cut some more? You decide if that's meaningful or not.

Anyways, a lot of your description in this was absolutely wonderful, and you did an awesome job of portraying the main character's feelings. Again, feel free to completely disregard anything you don't agree with, and take what helps. Happy writing!

BlackGhost

_________________
"...(smile)..." ~ Paul Harris

Hauntings - A Critique Shop
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address MSN Messenger
Aet Lindling   View This User's Portfolio
the Antitwilight.
Speaker of the Forum

141
Gender: Gender:Male
Age: 100
Joined: 26 Feb 2007
Posts: 740
Reviews: 141
Country: Careful, if I come into contact with idiocy I'll cause annihilation!
0 Points

PostPosted: Sun Aug 24, 2008 10:29 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

I love this piece, I had to read it a few times to get everything, and even still I think there are more layers waiting for me.

I think Black Ghost just wiped out anything I'd be able to find, so I don't really have anything to point out, except that it is something of an unrealistic coincidence for so many people to accidentally reveal their self-harming habits to her. Then again, that coincidence makes for a good story. Razz

Now, I must read it again.

_________________
"His skin literally sparkled, like thousands of tiny diamonds were embedded in the surface. He lay perfectly still in the grass, his shirt open over his sculpted, incandescent chest, his scintillating arms bare."

'Nuff said, amirite? Twihater yay.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Kyte   View This User's Portfolio
Fantasy guru
Master of the Forum

410
Gender: Gender:Male
Age: 17
Joined: 13 Aug 2007
Posts: 1062
Reviews: 410
Country: Somewhere in Florida
73 Points

PostPosted: Sun Aug 24, 2008 1:39 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I'm glad someone entered. I think the others already got the line-by-lines, so I'll just say "Thanks."

_________________
Oh, the humanity!
Black Cat Sachiko
We are the Folk, and tonight we speak in one voice of the deeds of all.
Tailchaser's Song
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
JFW1415   View This User's Portfolio
Team SPEW
Master of the Forum

367
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 14
Joined: 07 Jun 2007
Posts: 1288
Reviews: 367
Country: USA
1002 Points

PostPosted: Sun Aug 24, 2008 3:45 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Aet Lindling wrote:
I love this piece, I had to read it a few times to get everything, and even still I think there are more layers waiting for me.

I think Black Ghost just wiped out anything I'd be able to find, so I don't really have anything to point out, except that it is something of an unrealistic coincidence for so many people to accidentally reveal their self-harming habits to her. Then again, that coincidence makes for a good story. Razz

Now, I must read it again.

Well, the thing is, when you do it, you notice it everywhere. It's always on your mind. So for a normal person to notice it would be a bit weird, but for her it's just because she's on the lookout. Any ideas on how I can make that clearer?

And thank you so much Black Ghost! I've skimmed through your comments for now and see some really good points - I'll definitely give this a good editing with all those. xD

Thanks all!

~JFW1415

_________________
Man is least himself when he talks in his own person. Give him a mask, and he will tell you the truth. -Oscar Wilde

Join the CIA.

In response to hearing my new story idea: "Aunt April": Oookaaay. You are one sick little puppy aren't you?
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address MSN Messenger
ashleylee   View This User's Portfolio
I want the friction...
Master of the Forum

693
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 16
Joined: 13 Mar 2008
Posts: 1210
Reviews: 693
Country: some place that I can only dream about
960 Points

PostPosted: Sun Aug 24, 2008 6:10 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Gosh, this story was seriously depressing, JFW. But I felt that you did a great job really hitting the problem dead-on. It is like the people only think about It and what others would think. It’s like that’s all they care about anymore. I must praise you on how well you portrayed this! Very Happy

Well, I’m sorry that I have no corrections for you ‘cause I could find no mistakes. (and it seems the others really have you covered so I don't feel as bad Wink )

All I can say is to Keep Writing!

_________________
-Fill your paper with the breathings of your heart-
~William Wordsworth
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message MSN Messenger
Avens Dolor   View This User's Portfolio
Senior Writer

49
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 18
Joined: 16 Jun 2008
Posts: 116
Reviews: 49
Country: USA
500 Points

PostPosted: Thu Aug 28, 2008 3:47 pm    Post subject: Re: All There Is Reply with quote

Comments in red.


All There Is

Look both ways, make sure no one's watching. Turn the knob – don't let it creak – slip inside. Strip to your underwear, look at your pale thigh, at the faded scars, white beneath the fluorescent light.

Reach under the sink – past the shampoo and the conditioner and the body wash – get one out. Take it out of its case. Don't let it touch your fingers – too easy to slice, too easy to notice.

Bring it to your leg. Cool and loving, sharp and forgiving, pressed up against your skin. Slice. Tiny beads, dark red, a necklace for your leg. Wait – it'll sting soon.

Slice again and again and again until that's all that there is.

I like how poetic this is, but the last line is a little clumsy.

-----

All around you are people. They're to your right and to your left and behind you and in front of you and everywhere. I understand what you're trying to do here, but it doesn't really work. You're trying too hard for rhythm--just let it come to you. They push and shove and rush to get wherever they're going and don't turn back to look at the person who they forced out of the way, to look at you. "forced out of their way, too look at you" doesn't read very well. Make it crisp instead of winding.

You push your way through the crowd slowly, shying away you've used "way" already, so this sound weird. from every touch, but it's impossible. Limbs are entangled with limbs and you find it repulsing but there's no way out so you push on.

You pull you the side Uh... typo? to catch your breath. The bodies are still pressing but only on one side, pushing you out into the road, out in front of the still traffic. You turn so that they're only pressing against your back, and you brace yourself.

If you get hit by a car and end up in a hospital the doctors will see It. Usually the capitalization would be cheesy, but I actually think that it works here.

Across the road is a girl doing the same thing you are, in the same kind of clothes – a baggy, dreary colored sweatshirt, loose jeans, hair long and straggly. Your eyes are drawn to her, at the girl who could be your twin despite the golden hair and the sea colored eyes that don't match you at all. Um... Is this Spider Man? How can you see the color of someone's eyes when they're across the street?

She raises her arm to signal for a cab, and her sleeve falls down. You see It and It's all you can think about as you slip back into the crowd with all the normal people and she slips into the cab and you go opposite ways. Don't use "slip" twice, and come up with a more concise ending. This again is getting too quasi-poetic.

-----

The cab's not as crowded as the road had been, but it smells. The man in front doesn't apologize for this. "The woman just before you had four kids and three cats," he says in explanation. You nod but don't say anything. It's not the smell of children or of cats that's bothering you.

"Miss?" the man asks again, and he lifts his eyes from the road to look at you through the rearview mirror he's turned in The last half of this line makes no sense.. Your hand automatically goes to you leg, presses against it, and you force yourself not to wince.

He turns it in to watch the people he's a freak he's a spy he wants to know your secret… ...What? He turns what in? And where is your punctuation? This is very jumbled.

You turn the grimace What grimace? You must mention it first if you intend to refer back to it. to a smile then look out the window at all the people on the street who are walking faster than you're moving, but you'd till rather be in here with the smell. Every second you sit there costs you more and more money and you're wasting your time but you'd rather be broke and late than be out there where everyone's so close.

In front of you the reaches into the seat next to you What?, the seat in front of you, the one you can't see. Uh... What?! "You mind?" he asks, holding up a carton of Camel cigarettes and an orange lighter.

You go to shake your head, no, you don't mind, but it's already shaking. Your whole body is shaking and you can't stop it so you try to make it look like you're in control, you're always in control, you have to be in control…

It's not your Savior but you know it's someone's Savior and that scares you. Again, this makes no sense. Are you referring to the habit of smoking?

-----

You get out of that cab as fast as you can.

"Are you all right, Miss?" he asks when you tell him you want to get out. It's in the middle of the road but you're not moving and you won't be for a long time so you nod and open the door.

"Uh, Miss?" he asks as you're halfway out the door, your purse flying along behind you. "That's fifteen ninety."

You stare at him for a moment, with his cigarette dangling from the corner of his mouth and his smoke filling up the cab then shake your head, blink your eyes. You grab a few bills from your purse and shove them into his hands, pulling back quickly back "back quickly back" (typo) before the Savior can come near you.

-----

"Please, sit down," the woman says to you, gesturing to the chair in front of the desk. Is it her desk or some random desk? You stand at the doorway uncertainly, Change to "...doorway, uncertain, looking..." looking around the room, searching for any Saviors. You've seen too many today and you just want to get away from them all.

The office is huge. Behind the woman are two windows, wide open to reveal the sounds and smells and lights of New York. Along the walls are gleaming silver cabinets with white papers overflowing from them. On her desk in is a computer, keyboard, glass half empty, and a nameplate with her name etched into it. No Saviors in sight. "glass half empty" is way too obvious of a reference. Cut it.

You go over to the chair and sit down, perching on the edge. Change to "You perch on the edge of the chair" plus an end clause, if you prefer. In your hands is your resume, covering your black pencil skirt, even more protection from people seeing It.

Her eyes land on your leg, and you have to breath in deep, remind yourself that she's looking at the papers, not underneath. She's smiling at you as you raise your arm, hand over the papers. You pull back, bring the glass with you. It crashes onto the desk, water overflows, glass shatters.

The Saviors had been hiding.

"Shit!" she yells, jumping up and raising her arms up. "Shit shit shit shit shit…" She starts shoving the bits of jagged glass into a pile, the water sloshing around in a puddle on the wood, and you just sit there, unsure of what to do. This is unlikely. A professional woman is not going to start screaming "shit" over and over again in front of a potential employee.

"Uh, up there," the woman says, nodding her head towards a cabinet, her hands busy scraping together the remnants of her glass. "Paper towels, fourth row up – shit!"

You nod, rip your gaze away from the Saviors, stand up from your seat. You instantly ache for the comfort of the padded chair once more, the secure arms guarding you, but you push forward and walk to the cabinets, search through the fourth drawer, take out the paper towels.

As you turn to face the woman again, paper towels in hand, you see her hastily shoving the sharpest piece of glass into her pocket How can you tell that it's the sharpest piece of glass? Have you been studying them and measuring their angles?. She freezes – the towels fall to the floor – and the room becomes eerily silent.

Finally her mouth closes from the shock, and she withdraws her hand from her pocket. Her eyes flicker down to the paper towels at your feet, and you hastily bend down, pick them up, hand them to her.

"Thank… thank you," she says, not looking you in the eye as you set them on the desk, the bottom of every single layer becoming soaked through. "I'll give you a call if anything comes up."

You nod and walk out of the room.

-----

You don't take the cab home because you're afraid you'll get Him again and He does It and It's not good and you want it gone gone gone gone gone…

So you go through the crowd again. They push and shove and control you but at least you aren't confined anymore. You can slip into the road – no car's moving anyway – and leave for a minute when you run out of air.

One big breath in. It has to last for a long time breathe slowly don't waste it only so much left… Ginormous run-on.

You slip back into the crowd, hold your purse close to your body, let yourself be drawn closer and closer the to your apartment building.

There's the door. Straight ahead.

You pull apart from the crowd as soon as you get there, gasping and wheezing for breath, your hands on your knees, head lowered. "Miss?" says the doorman, and you jerk your head up to see him. He's smiling down at you with one hand folded behind his back and the other holding open the door for you but it doesn't look real. He's too clean and press-cut I don't think that "press-cut" is the right conjugation for this sentence. and you wonder if he's actually there.

You straighten yourself and go to walk through the door, but you trip in the doorway, and your arms and legs and purse go flying everywhere. His arm jerks out to grab you, and his flesh is warm and strong on yours.

You pull away from his hand and gather your legs and your arms and your purse, then stand up, refusing his help. His arm is still there, extended out for you to lean on, but it's the one that he had kept hidden.

It's purple and swollen and bloody and he hasn't been in a fight.

You offer his him a forced smile and slip through the doorway, straight to the elevator and up the seven flights to your apartment.

You reach your floor. The wood echoes under your heels as you clip, clip, clip down the hall, past room 702, 704, 706, finally reach your number.

The hall is empty, but you still shove the key into the door, slip inside, lock the door behind you. All fast – very fast – because someone could be watching. Someone's always watching.

But your apartment feels empty and you drop your purse on the couch, the empty couch, and walk through the empty living room to the empty hall and into the empty bathroom.

The door closes with a click behind you and you stand there, hands on either side of the porcelain sink, the material Pick a more descriptive word than "material". cold beneath your finger. Just the one finger? You stare at your reflection for seconds, minutes, hours, days, not recognizing the woman before you, not understanding how someone so broken could possibly be you.

You reach under the sink and take out your Savior of choice.

-----

You don't care so much this time because you know you're not alone and this isn't a bad way to escape everything because there wouldn't be so many people doing It if it were.

The metal is cool and familiar in your hand as you bring it to your bare leg and prepare to redden the pale skin below the lines – the sets of three perfect lines – that you made yesterday.

Everyone does it. Everyone does it. Everyone does it.

You slice. You slice again and again and again until that's all That there is. Still don't like this line.


Okay, well first off you probably could've given it another read-through because there were many typos Wink

Other than that, it isn't bad. I have a hard time believing how many cutters you might run into in one day who would be that obvious about it, but for the sake of the story I won't complain too much. I was confused for a long time about the "Savior". It sounded like you meant people at first--people who would know and try to get you help. Then I realized what you really meant. I think that "Savior" is too strong/cliche of a word for the situation.

Also, you get into a lot of mock-poetic language which is detrimental. There are many lines in there that sound as if you think and want them to be awesome and poetic, but the best lines are the ones which have a natural rhythm and aren't forced. Review, review, review is the only advice that anyone can give for this.

Over all well done, and I'll be waiting for your next piece!

Avens

_________________
Click to visit my author blog!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
JFW1415   View This User's Portfolio
Team SPEW
Master of the Forum

367
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 14
Joined: 07 Jun 2007
Posts: 1288
Reviews: 367
Country: USA
1002 Points

PostPosted: Fri Aug 29, 2008 10:13 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Edited. Please critique!

And thank you all sooo much, especially Black Ghost - you've all made very good points and I've tried to incorporate most of your thoughts in here. I think you'll be pleased with the result.

And again, when you cut, you DO notice this many people. I see them all the time. But I agree it's strange to see this many in a story, so I reworked it.

~JFW1415

_________________
Man is least himself when he talks in his own person. Give him a mask, and he will tell you the truth. -Oscar Wilde

Join the CIA.

In response to hearing my new story idea: "Aunt April": Oookaaay. You are one sick little puppy aren't you?
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address MSN Messenger
Black Ghost   View This User's Portfolio
Life Is Sexually Transmitted
Speaker of the Forum

276
Gender: Gender:Male
Age: 17
Joined: 04 Feb 2006
Posts: 986
Reviews: 276
Country: The Edge of Inspiration
300 Points

PostPosted: Fri Aug 29, 2008 11:23 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I like the way you reworked it. You still get across that it's all she thinks about (seeing Saviors everywhere she goes) without making any of the situations far-fetched in the least. ^^ It's a lot more realistic this way, but still gets the same message across. Awesome. Razz

BlackGhost

_________________
"...(smile)..." ~ Paul Harris

Hauntings - A Critique Shop
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address MSN Messenger
dreamintechnicolour   View This User's Portfolio
Writer

15
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 16
Joined: 08 Aug 2008
Posts: 89
Reviews: 15
Country: New Zealand
326 Points

PostPosted: Sat Aug 30, 2008 12:30 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I really liked this. It was powerfully written and you have an amazing way with the second person (which most people can't do).

Just a few little things which I would change:

Quote:
The cab you had been signaling before you saw her pulls up in front of you, blocking the spot the girl had been.

Get rid of “before you saw her”, it just slows things down.



Quote:
The lighter's not your Savior but you know it's someone's Savior and that scares you

“The lighter may not be your Savoir, but you know it's someone else’s, and that scares you” - This makes it more clear and not as repetitive.



Quote:
You don't take the cab home because you're afraid you'll get him again and he does It. It's not good and you want It gone but It's everywhere…

Consistent capitalization is important here. You said at the top of your story that the taxi driver doesn’t burn… But then you say here that he does… And there’s nowhere else in the story that says he does… This needs fixing up.



Quote:
The air's still and the room's quiet but you still sneak into your bathroom because someone could be watching.

“Even though the air is still and the room is quiet, you sneak into your bathroom, just because someone could be watching.” – This makes it nicer to read, the rhythm is improved.



Quote:
Look both ways, make sure no one's watching. Turn the knob – don't let it creak – slip inside. Strip to your underwear, look at your pale thigh, at the faded scars. You're legs are white beneath the fluorescent light, but they're covered with lines of red.
Reach under the sink – past the shampoo and the conditioner and the body wash – get one out. Take it out of its case, but don't put it on the stick – you're not shaving. Don't let it touch your fingers – too easy to slice, too easy to notice.

I think you need to establish the whole savior thing at