z

Young Writers Society


The Tattoo Engineer - 1.2 (Revised)



User avatar
262 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 1193
Reviews: 262
Thu May 19, 2011 1:38 am
ultraviolet says...



JOIN THE CLUB =3

Summary:

Spoiler! :
Adah Edric, a banished princess, has been staying at a neighboring country under a fake name. Her father has recently died and her brother, Nicholas, has taken the throne. Nicholas has located her and requests she comes home. She doesn't want to, but she agrees under the terms of becoming a soldier and training with her childhood friend, Garret.


In the morning, I return everything the school borrowed me to the dresser in my room, then pull on the only clothes I came with - brown pants, a plain long sleeve shirt, a plaid vest, and soft boots. I haven’t grown much in the two years I’ve been here, so they’re only a little snug. As I final touch, I fasten on a string necklace Gavin gave me that has an underdeveloped pinecone for a pendant.
I pack my few other things in a beige carpetbag no bigger than a large purse, which has more room than I need.
I travel down the back stairs, careful for no one to see me. I don’t need any awkward goodbyes, anyone telling me to stay, and certainly not anyone questioning why I’m leaving. The answer’s too close to why I came. They can assume I’m an Adair - someone at one point forced to sell their body out of poverty. Those leave without warning all the time, though no one knows where they go. Of course, there's probably only one person here who might actually care if they caught me, but if I run into her... this would be a lot harder to do.
Outside, I skip through maintenance paths to the main building. It’s stopped raining, but everything’s still saturated with moisture. With high canopied trees and sprawling undergrowth crossing over the cobblestone paths, that’s not surprising. It can sometimes take the greater part of the day for the dew to evaporate.
At the door to the main building, I pause. Do I really want to do this? No, but I have to; if I don’t, he won’t allow Gavin into the military. And I can’t let that happen - I owe it to him to come back. And, despite my reluctance to admit it, there’s a part of me that’s excited for coming back. Not just to see Gavin again or be his training partner - though that’s a miracle in and of itself - but because I miss the cool weather and the dry woods. I miss my bow and arrows. I miss home. I just don’t miss the people.
Taking a deep breath, I push through the door. The main building is like the cafeteria in that it’s large - much larger than it appears from the outside - and also in its frequent use. Students congregate here regularly for lectures, announcements, dances, tutoring sessions, and a number of clubs that meet weekly, none of which I’ve had any part in. Right now, it’s empty save for a man standing by the entrance whose brown hair has tastefully bleached tips that no other dignified person could pull off.
The man sees me then departs, and I follow him. The air out by the drive is muggy, as though the fat drops of rain hang suspended and I’m plowing through them with each step. Passing palm trees, we both climb in a small black limousine, where the air conditioning saves us from the humidity.
Speaking for the first time, the man, who sits facing me, says, “We’ve never met. My name is Vanadis,” and daringly holds out his hand.
Not hesitating, I take it. “Adah Edric.”
You can tell he’s impressed with my disregard of snobbish royal customs - that is, shaking a commoners hand. I’m impressed he gave me the option.
And though yes, we’ve never met, never spoken to each other, I know him - know of him. He was my brother’s escort - meaning little more than babysitter. But he had a reputation of being too bold and behaving as others dared not. And while my parents adored him, I was never allowed near him for fear I’d learn bad habits, though apparently they didn‘t hold this concern to my brother. I guess my brother thinks I’m mature enough to handle his influence.
The rest of the short one mile ride to the train station, neither of us says anything, but I can feel his eyes on me, though I look away, out the window. Not necessarily out of embarrassment, but because I somehow feel he has the right to look me over. It's hard to think I'll never see any of what's out the window again while squirming under his stare, though.
The limousine stops, and I’m forced to go back out in the weather I hate. We walk hastily to one of the platforms and climb aboard a large, black train. The ticketmaster says nothing to us, so I assume we’re expected, that it was all worked out ahead of time. I wonder if he would have recognized me otherwise. I wonder if he would have pretended not to.
We pass through several passenger cars to a private one near the back. Inside is a sitting room with short, long couches and minute tables. I sit on a couch swathed in purple velvet. Vanadis draws two bottles of water from a miniature fridge and sits at a chair opposite me, then hands me a water. I accept and take a sip that moistens my dry throat.
The trained rumbles and through a window I can see we’re moving. I’m not really sad to see the island atmosphere leave as we transfer over a bridge that connects the tracks to the mainland, though I feel I probably should be.
“When we get back,” Vanadis says, “there are a few things you should know. First of all, the evaluations have recently been completed and there is going to be a feast tonight for the high-rated.”
I nod. It’s the last week in May; I’d already been expecting this.
“You will not only be expected to attend the feast, you will have to make a speech. Which, of course, I will recite to you through an ear piece. You will not alter a single word of what I tell you, and you will say it with all the emotion you can drag up, as though you wrote this.”
I take another sip; the salty island air made me perpetually thirsty.
“And lastly, you do not speak of your banishment. You do not recall your pain or struggle or anger; you do not pretend that it’s made you stronger; you do not so much as speak a word on how it’s affected you. If someone brings it up, thank them for their concern and quickly change the subject. If they press, I’m sure there’s another hopeless busybody for you to converse with. Is this clear?”
I know he's right, of course, but I grit my teeth. Does he really think he has to tell me this? Why would I talk about that to people I never met and didn’t care about? Because I like throwing the humiliation up in the air? Because I like reminding everyone of how my own father sent me away? Because I want to add injury to insult?
“Is this clear?” His eyes dig into me.
“Very,” I say.
Even while sitting casually in plain suit pants and a simple button down shirt, there's an air of charisma about him, as though he's royalty, not I. As if anything that comes from his mouth must be right, must be true, and must be obeyed, not like my brother must be, but rather because he really does make you think that he has all the answers and therefor everything will turn out well if you trust him. I understand now why my parents never wanted the younger me near him; I would have believed anything this man said.
“Good. I didn’t expect you’d think otherwise.” He stands. “Now, if you’ll excuse me, I have some business to attend to before we stop at the border.”
He leaves, and I’m left wondering exactly what sort of position he’ll take in my life; one of mutual respect, or one of great tension.
I ride alone for a while, drinking the rest of my water and watching as the scenery transforms from the tropical coastline to a more mild farmland atmosphere. I'm amazed at how unattached I feel about the changes and about how I'm leaving and will never come back. I'm not sure if I'm simply numb, or if I really don't care; and I'm not sure which is worse. After allowing me in, giving me opportunities like the one I took when the Headmistress found me, can I really feel so little toward the country?
Of course, I'm not completely detached. There are a few things I'll miss, some things I know I'll never get again. Freedom to live without constant judgement. Freedom to act and dress and eat how I will. Freedom to not rely on everyone else for my needs. And a friend like Cassia, who helped me without knowing or caring who I was.
But still, if the situation I'm returning to were different, would I even think twice about leaving? Sometimes, my own detachment scares me.
My insides feel like ice when the train stops and Vanadis fetches me.
We exit onto a large platform with hundreds of people milling about. A tall, electrified fence runs parallel on each side, extending as far as, I imagine, the shores on each end of the continent. This fence divides Ithe, the country I’d been staying at, and Amhain, my country. Or which was my country. On the platform are three massive buildings. Vanadis takes me to the far left one.
“Passport and papers,” a man drones from behind a wooden ticket booth. Like the three other booths in the room, the top half is boxed in with steel rods, as though they’re afraid one of us will launch at them with a crowbar. Though, I can’t help thinking, working border duty, there have to be characters who would do anything to get past the bolted door into the neighboring country. I wonder their solution if someone brought in a gun.
Vanadis slides a metal ID sheet through a slot. “I think this will do.”
The man scans it and looks up at us, blinking, as though in a stupor. “Uh - yes, Sir.” He slides the ID sheet, along with two stamped tickets, back through the slot.
Vanadis takes one ticket and hands me the other as we move towards the security doors, manned by armed guards, where a strangely large line has formed. It’s a weird concept, since the last time I came through here, it was almost deserted. But I suppose since Amhain is hosting the Fields this year, wealthy spectators are swarming the country.
I'm trying to decide which is more lonely, leaving my country with absolutely no one by my side, or returning to it in a room full of people I'd rather not know, when I find myself at the front of the line. The guard runs my ticket through a machine and waves me on. Thick metal poles stacked horizontal across a doorway, which are normally rigid, yield at my touch and I pass through easily. The cold steel sends shivers up my spine as a memory attempts to surface. I shove it down and walk through a vaulted door that slides open before me.
Vanadis meets me on the other side and we board another train, which soon launches from the platform. He informs me that soon a team of beauticians will appear to prepare me for the feast, and leaves to retrieve my dress. I sit, once again alone, as I wait for them.
This time, I'm not thinking of the country I'm leaving; but what about the one that awaits? I have no idea how they'll receive me, if they'll even pretend as though they're happy for my return. I don't think I want them to; it'd be so much easier to be glared at, spat at, criticized openly than to be admired and loved when everyone knows its only a charade. But does anyone dare disapprove of the king's decision? Not if he's anything like the previous one, and I think I know him well enough to say he'll be worse.
I don't even think about what will happen after the feast - I push away the hole in my stomach - because that's too much. I try not to think about anything at all as the beauticians work on me and as I wait for the train to stop.
By the time we arrive at the palace grounds, I am entirely sick of waiting around for things.

So, I guess by now people pretty much know what sort of things I prefer in a review. I've been in a slump lately, which I only recently got out of, so if this is disjointed, that's probably why. I should probably fix this up more before posting, but right now I'm pretty anxious to just get this out here, so here it is. But it's lovely, amazing, full of wonderful, interesting prose, and poetry-like sentences, and has characters and plot much too sophisticated for anyone who doesn't love it to understand. (Happy, Skinsles?) So, do your worst.
Last edited by ultraviolet on Tue Jun 21, 2011 2:50 pm, edited 7 times in total.
"Blah blah blah. You feel trapped in your life. Here is what I am hearing: happiness isn't worth any inconvenience."

~asofterworld.com
  





User avatar
253 Reviews

Supporter


Gender: Female
Points: 17359
Reviews: 253
Thu May 19, 2011 2:51 am
View Likes
RacheDrache says...



I was on this like a frog to a lilypad. Hehe.

Anyway, hello. I hope I'm your first response. I do enjoy being the first person to respond so. It's like being the first person to take a slice of pie. All the filling goes everywhere and the crust crumbles, but you got it FIRST. And it's sweeter for it. But this is me, not your story, so let's go onto that, shall we?

[ramble]

You had some typos in here that made me giggle, but I won't point them out because someone else probably will and if not, you can get them yourself. They're not exactly hidden. And they're far from important.

Some general thoughts...

I was genuinely shocked when the bleached hair and limo were mentioned. I think I had a more traditional fantasy in mind...despite the fact that this is in Action/Adventure Novels and I ought to know better. Oops. Anyway, it was a pleasant surprise, and I'm even more intrigued by the general premise. Doesn't hurt that you had a train, and I love trains. The bit about the etched metal was also cool, though I'm wondering why she noted it was a piece of 'etched metal' and not whatever the etched metal was called, unless she had no clue what it was, in which case her confusion could be more clear... she's a member of this world, so she'd see it as what it is, right? I mean, you don't look at a TV remote and think, "hm, a longish plastic object with buttons", right?

Two particular moments of dialogue stuck out at me as being particular strong, and I got all excited. When Vanadis is speaking to her in the train, that was particularly well done, I thought. Even though you didn't tag it extensively, and even though we didn't get a particularly good grasp on Vanadis (more on him later), I heard that dialogue, man. I heard the warnings. And best of all, even though you've barely mentioned anything about the political climate and culture of Adah's home country, I started to get an idea of what she's walking into. And that was so exciting. Delicious, really.

My other favorite dialogue moment was with the guard. While V-man's "I think you'll find these more than adequate" was somewhat cliche (but if he has a flair for the dramatic, then it works), the guard's response was great. You didn't go on about his stammer or his shock or anything, and Adah didn't wonder about what was on the piece of metal, but I could see that exchange going down quite clearly.

The train ride, though, was somewhat boring. The dialogue exchange between her and Vanadis was the best part (and great at that) but... she just sort of sits there, and we get none of the intensity before. Her question-thoughts back at Vanadis are good...but does she really just sit there and stare out the window? She's not pacing around in thought? Is she regretting leaving? Does she have any idea of what she's getting herself into?

Or is sitting and staring out the window how a princess deals with such things? If it is, though... what about her thoughts? What's she thinking about as the world goes by? What's her opinion on all this?

And I want to be endlessly intrigued by the Vanadis guy. How is he standing there in that room. When she sees him as just "a man" it makes him seem so insignificant. Does he have charisma? Power? I heard charsima and power when he spoke of what she must and must no do, but I want the physical description to go along with the dialogue. They don't necessarily have to match, and we can be utterly surprised that something like that came out of a man like that, but... More from Vanadis is my overall point there.

And more from Adah and her narrative... the reader's intrigue's gotta be sustained, right? You present a conflict in this chapter--all these pressures that are going to be on Adah--but because she doesn't do anything with them, we don't make anything of them, and it's just a train ride from A to B, nothing more than a transition between places in the story.

Don't make it just a transition. Don't be afraid to expand it and make it is own monster. The way to do that is through Adah, because she's returning home. From exile. I want to know more about that.

Annnnnnd....I think that's it. You've got characters and a world and a situation I want to know more about, so have fun with it, and laugh a little evil laugh.

Per usual, let me know if you have any questions.... wait, nope, not done yet.

a long wooden desk boxed in with steel rods


Has she never seen one before? This is like the etched metal, the TV remote. You don't get the same liberty as a 3rd person narrator to describe what certain things look like in particular ways. You have to be sneaky about it (the man sticking his hand through the metal bars, drumming his fingers on the wooden desk, etc.)

Same goes for other things. If she's aware of the reader, though, she can name it first and then describe it for the reader's benefit. Or be sneaky. But it's silly for her to describe and never name. Does that make sense?

And now I'm done. Hit my Wall with any questions/comments/concerns/ideas you want to talk about, and we can chat it up OCPD style.

Rach
I don't fangirl. I fandragon.

Have you thanked a teacher lately? You should. Their bladder control alone is legend.
  





User avatar
721 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 7241
Reviews: 721
Thu May 19, 2011 4:11 am
View Likes
Azila says...



Dangit. I was actually online when you posted this, and I thought I'd be first to review--but by the time I finished the review I was doing at the time, my family had called me over to do something, and when I got back Rachael had been here. Not only that, but she'd pointed out most of the things I wanted to get to! D: I just can't win. But I'll try to help out anyhow.

So. Like Rachael said, your dialogue is probably the strongest part of this chapter. It feels really alive, and I can definitely imagine actual characters saying all of it. I also think your descriptions in general are very nice. They're minimal but masterful, hinting at things just enough to give me a picture of what your settings are like without overdoing it. Actually, come to think of it, you have very little description really. But I still feel like I can picture everything quite clearly since you did a good job of setting the stage for my imagination to fill in the rest. I'm very impressed--usually I'm a description junkie, but you've convinced me that excessive descriptions aren't always needed.

I know Rachael already said this too (darn you, Rachael!) but the main thing that strikes me when I read this chapter is how little of your main characters thoughts were in the piece. Not only that, but she seems emotionless. Not having any emotions would be alright if it was in third person, because maybe she just doesn't show her emotions--but if it's in first person, then we really need to have access to her thoughts and her feelings. We should feel like we're inside her head, experiencing everything as she does. There's a lot of waiting in this chapter (as Adah acknowledges) so I'd like to see what she's thinking during that time.

Also, this is a big changing point in her life--I think she'd have stronger feelings about it. She feels very detached. Maybe you want her to be detached? If so, I think she should notice that. In an "I look numbly over the things that I may never see again and don't know what to feel" kind of way. But if you don't have any mention of her emotions, it ends up coming off a bit dry. Plus, it makes the whole thing seem a lot less important than it actually is.

And: did you skip over the part with the beauticians on the train? I'm not sure if you're saying that that happened between the last and second to last paragraphs, or if you're saying it will happen in the next chapter.

So. Good chapter. This revision is really looking great so far! But I do think you could use to flesh it out a bit to make Adah feel more three-dimensional. It's a tad bare right now.

As always, let me know if you have questions or anything!

a
  





User avatar
770 Reviews

Supporter


Gender: Female
Points: 30301
Reviews: 770
Thu May 19, 2011 1:55 pm
borntobeawriter says...



Violet!

Well, now that you've got two great reviews, I'm not sure what to add.

Can I be honest? I was almost skimming over this, there was so little happening. I remember mentioning before that we have so little of her thoughts, and it's glaringly obvious here.

I mean, I get that she doesn't want any messy goodbyes, but isn't there someone she cares for here? No attachement to anyone, after two years of being there? Maybe she could leave a note to someone, or at least think of that person. Yes?

Vanadis, as everyone mentioned, is a good strong character and it's always interesting to read more of him. But Adah? Not so much. She's going through a crap-load of stuff but from her lack of reaction, you'd swear she was in the middle of a boring math class. I get why she's doing it, but that doesn't mean she has to like it. Yet, no thought process here, no anger at being pulled out, no murderous dreams about her brother because she's mad that he's making her do this.

Maybe I'm just blood-thirsty, but really, shouldn't there be more?

OTher than that, the dialogue was great and I can'T wait to read more.

Keep up the great work!

Tanya
  





User avatar
262 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 1193
Reviews: 262
Thu May 19, 2011 3:11 pm
ultraviolet says...



I've edited this. I'm not sure if I'm actually portraying her emotions all the well, or enough, or whatever, but I suppose it's up to you to decide that. Would anyone mind taking another look at it?
"Blah blah blah. You feel trapped in your life. Here is what I am hearing: happiness isn't worth any inconvenience."

~asofterworld.com
  





User avatar
253 Reviews

Supporter


Gender: Female
Points: 17359
Reviews: 253
Fri May 20, 2011 1:40 am
View Likes
RacheDrache says...



I'm baaaaaaack! (And I bet I'll beat Azila too... mwahahahahaha)

Okay, so don't freak out about the upcoming text wall. Just pay attention to the bolded words...and my various ramblings...and...other stuff....Basically, don't freak out.

It's hard to think I'll never see any of what's out the window again while squirming under his stare, though.

I'm amazed at how unattached I feel about the changes and about how I'm leaving and will never come back. I'm not sure if I'm simply numb, or if I really don't care; and I'm not sure which is worse. After allowing me in, giving me opportunities like the one I took when the Headmistress found me, can I really feel so little toward the country?

Of course, I'm not completely detached. There are a few things I'll miss, some things I know I'll never get again. Freedom to live without constant judgement. Freedom to act and dress and eat how I will. Freedom to not rely on everyone else for my needs. And a friend like Cassia, who helped me without knowing or caring who I was.

But still, if the situation I'm returning to were different, would I even think twice about leaving? Sometimes, my own detachment scares me.

My insides feel like ice when the train stops and Vanadis fetches me.

Though, I can’t help thinking, working border duty, there have to be characters who would do anything to get past the bolted door into the neighboring country. I wonder their solution if someone brought in a gun.

I'm trying to decide which is more lonely, leaving my country with absolutely no one by my side, or returning to it in a room full of people I'd rather not know, when I find myself at the front of the line.

This time, I'm not thinking of the country I'm leaving; but what about the one that awaits? I have no idea how they'll receive me, if they'll even pretend as though they're happy for my return. I don't think I want them to; it'd be so much easier to be glared at, spat at, criticized openly than to be admired and loved when everyone knows its only a charade. But does anyone dare disapprove of the king's decision? Not if he's anything like the previous one, and I think I know him well enough to say he'll be worse.

I don't even think about what will happen after the feast - I push away the hole in my stomach - because that's too much. I try not to think about anything at all as the beauticians work on me and as I wait for the train to stop.


That's a lot of bolded 'feels' and 'thinks'. I'm hoping the visual impact of all that bold will make my point... but that's a heck of a lot of bold! At the very least, 'tis repetitious. But, more than that.

What's the problem with 'feel' and 'think'? They are 'tell' words, 9 times out of 10, possibly more like 23/24 or 87/93. In other words, she's just saying, "I feel ____" and "I feel ____" and while we get the detachment because there's not emotion otherwise... well, she's just telling us what she thinks and feels.

And then you use words like the ones I put in blue (frogs, I hope I put them in blueish), which are the adjectives of how she feels, but again, she's just telling us she feels blank, and we don't know what blank feels like or how she knows she's feeling blank.

And thinking... obviously, if it crops up in the narrative, she was thinking about it. If she she's mentioning it, she has to know it somehow, so you don't have to say that she 'knows' it...(though you could to produce a certain effect.)

This all comes back, basically, to good ole, "Show, don't tell." We're given handy adjectives that describe what she's feeling and such, but...

I guess things are a little different because this is in first person, and so there's a distinct, living narrator, and technically, Adah can use as many feels and thinks and stuff as she wants, because she's the one narrating. And maybe she's convinced she's detached. Maybe she is detached. Maybe she's lying to herself. I dunno.

I guess you have to think about layers. There's the layer of what she's expressly overtly, the layer of what she's not saying, and the layer of what we as readers interpret. Your best friend can tell you all she wants that she's "Fine" and "Nothing's" wrong but you know better than to believe her.

We're not at bff status with Adah yet, so we're not going to know necessarily if she's lying to us... but there still can be a different layer to it.

You tell us in sum what she thought about the entire train ride there, but why not show us those thoughts? I don't mean bust everything out in italics, because people rarely think in nice coherent strings of words. But she has memories too, and she could run through scenarios of what might happen when she gets home, or run through scenarios of what her friend will do when she discovers Adah's gone. Just don't tell us, "I think about what might happen, or what Cassie will do when she discovers me gone."

Is this making sense? Bad Ribbit.

I understand you wanting to get ahead to where the plot and juicy stuff starts, but this isjuicy stuff. Even if she's just sitting there in a train all by herself, staring out the window, what she thinks or doesn't think is important. Not important in the sense necessarily of us needing to know that she thought about X and Y and Z and felt this way down to the scientific definition of the term. But reading her thoughts and predictions and actions there as she's by herself will tell us loads about her. Loads more than we'll ever know if she's just telling us straight out.

As it is with this edit, I'm still more interested in the things like the metal etching and the electric fence than in the conflict that drove her away from home and the conflict bringing her back. I don't get the emotion of why going back to save Gavin's dreams is so important now. I felt it in the first chapter, not because you said she was pissed but because her anger and frustration radiated. She can radiate a cool calm and detachment now too... but it has to be clear. And she can radiate cool calm and apathy while still building the tension and suspense.

And this is random, but the thought just occurred to me. Is she really just standing there in line, doing nothing? The moment where she's contemplating what they'd do if someone brought a gun is nice--a really nice moment, really, because it shows us the things she cares about--but what about Vanadis? Isn't he supposed to be some intimidating presence?

This brings me to my next thing:

Even while sitting casually in plain suit pants and a simple button down shirt, there's an air of charisma about him, as though he's royalty, not I. As if anything that comes from his mouth must be right, must be true, and must be obeyed, not like my brother must be, but rather because he really does make you think that he has all the answers and therefor everything will turn out well if you trust him. I understand now why my parents never wanted the younger me near him; I would have believed anything this man said.


What is this air of charisma? What does it look like, and how does she know it's there?

The answer is in his body language. Think of a person you know or a character in a movie who radiates charisma--or an actor--and think of how they sit, how they hold themselves. You've already got the dialogue down. His dialogue speaks volumes for who he is, and I'm believing in the power of this man long before I get to this paragraph. But rather than tell us that he has an air of charisma, describe it.

Her reaction to him characterizes him too. Her "Very" told me that she has strength and confidence despite the power of this man, but you didn't write, "I feel confidant despite the power of this man" now did you? You left it for the reader to interpret, as you should.

So, again, 'tis the show-don't-tell issue.

That said.... good job with the specifying your nouns, let me know if you have any questions, come bug me on my Wall with any comments or concerns, etc. etc.

Rach
I don't fangirl. I fandragon.

Have you thanked a teacher lately? You should. Their bladder control alone is legend.
  





User avatar
1087 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 44360
Reviews: 1087
Fri May 20, 2011 8:13 pm
Sins says...



*Groans. Loudly*

Geez, I'm going to look stupid now. Azila? Rach? Twice?. *Eats her own brain.* Okay, no, I can do this... xD To be honest, I think this is going to be more of a comment than a review. I'm awful at reviewing things that have been edited when I've already read the original version, plus, you know, Rach, Azila, Tanya and all that. :P So yeah, sorry if this is kind of lame...

Before I begin...

But it's lovely, amazing, full of wonderful, interesting prose, and poetry-like sentences, and has characters and plot much too sophisticated for anyone who doesn't love it to understand. (Happy, Skinsles?)

Sarcasm doesn't count. ;)

When it comes to the chapter as a whole, I'm confident in saying that I can certainly see an improvement! Not that you version before was bad or anything, of course not, but I can see that you've done a great edit here. Like the others have said, I think you've nailed the dialogue here. It was both interesting and realistic, so that's awesome. I really liked your descriptions and such too. I'm terrible at descriptions, to be honest, so I must say that I am rather jealous. You've got a good balance with your descriptions--the piece isn't being drowned in them, but it doesn't feel empty of them either. Great job!

Sigh... I'm going to have to repeat things... >.< Why do you have to have such awesome reviewers?! Whyyy?!

Part of me kind of wants this to be in third person. Don't take offence by that or anything, but I just think this would work rather well in third person when it comes to your style of the novel so far. Don't get me wrong, it works lovely in first person--and I'm not saying you should change the POV at all--but like the others have said, the detached feel makes it all feel more, err, detached. Before you start going into panic mode, stooooop. Compared to the tone of Adah at the very beginning of this in the original version, the tone in this feels far more personal and less detached. Basically, I know you're improving with it and I really do admire you for that. So yeah, a thumbs up overall!

The other guys have mentioned this, so I don't want to go into a ramble about it. You've got some great advice from them too, so me adding some would probably baffle you completely. What I will say though is that you shouldn't get stressed or anything about it. Like I said, I've noticed a definite improvement so far. All you need is some more practice, methinks, and we'll soon be feeling like Adah is our lifelong soul mate.

To be honest, that's all that's bothered me here... I notice, like, nothing Rachael mentions... :lol: I guess I'm not fussy... or Rach and Ribbit just know, like, everything there is to know about writing and probably life too...

The moral of this story is... Awesome job!

Keep writing, and I swear I'll be helpful in the next review,

xoxo Skins
I didn't know what to put here so I put this.
  





User avatar
816 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 44887
Reviews: 816
Tue May 24, 2011 6:32 pm
View Likes
Shearwater says...



Ugh, I'm so late.

Um, yo!

I hate being late because I know everyone will get to it first and pluck out all the nice round grapes and I'll be in the thorns trying to pick out raisins. :/ That made no sense but let's just go with it, okay? My brain is going to be fried after this because it's going to be like getting juice out of a raisin that I plucked. Oh god, all these awesome reviews...twice...with something that's already been revised. God, you just want to kill us, don't you? >.>

Anyway, let's see if I have anything to say...

Um, not really. Not that anyone before me has already mentioned so I guess no raisin juice for you. Shucks, I know you were looking forward to it, too. Anyway, as far as this chapter goes, It's good. I can see the improvement from before and I bet if you were to write it again and again, each time would be better than the last. Now, knowing this you'll have to make a derision if you want to keep editing or go ahead. Sometimes you know your character a lot better after you've written five or six chapters in your novel. If you get distracted by these little details now, you might loose your creative juices and end up getting a headache from all the revisions. I know this is probably only your second or third time revising this but let me tell you that you shouldn't stop pouring your juice yet just because there's something in the glass or because the taste isn't right since you picked some rotten grapes while in the field.

I'm all up for revision, don't let them knock you down though. I'd edited my novel like five times - just the first chapter and it still annoys me but if I keep going back, I'll never be able to go forward. You still have time to fix things and I want to read what happens next. However! All the advice that was given to you, they're great and I would look at them and learn from them and use that to revise and to continue writing. There's no such thing as perfection so don't be totally angry if it isn't exactly like Welches juice or whatever. Why do I keep referring to grape juice? I dunno. Anyway, back to the point - don't let it get you down.

Wow, that was helpful. =__=
For the characters and all, I'm on the same boat as the others. I like how you were able to explain her feelings here and you had some wonderful sentences too to make it feel all nice and fluffy. I'm still having this mysterious vibes over Vanadis, which is a good thing. His character is pretty interesting and I want to know about their relationship with each other and what truly lies beneath the covers of this tale. ;)

Overall, it's good and I like it - happy?
I'll be waiting for more. Again, sorry for being late and sorry for this crappy review. Honestly, being the last reviewer is usually my spot and I never really have anything important to say after that so I end up rambling on about something to fill space. Hopefully my presence here was enough if my words weren't. xD

Happy writing and let me know if you need anything else! I'll try to be more helpful next time and get to it first so I won't have to ramble on like this again. =P

See ya, Ultra! <3

-Pink

(Blame Skins for my lateness. I had to review her novel first. >.>)
There are three rules for writing a novel. Unfortunately, no one knows what they are.
-W. Somerset Maugham
  








"I'd be a quote vigilante. A literary Batman. Someone had better be quoting me now!"
— Feltrix