z

Young Writers Society


Bestial Conflict - Chapter 1 - Revised



User avatar
91 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 12142
Reviews: 91
Thu Sep 02, 2010 12:36 pm
Wolferion says...



~ Deleted from existence ~
Last edited by Wolferion on Sat Sep 24, 2011 1:23 pm, edited 4 times in total.
~Don't beg for things, do it yourself or else you'll never get anything~
-Formerly Shinda
  





User avatar
213 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 15813
Reviews: 213
Thu Sep 02, 2010 10:46 pm
SporkPunk says...



Kyou! It's me again, here as requested! :D

First, before I truly begin, thanks for having me read this again. I feel like you found my review really helpful, which is awesome! Also, I think it's kind of amazing that you're writing a novel in your non-native language. :)

Grammar:

Much, much improved from the original! That's great! The only thing I could really find wrong grammatically was that you left out some articles, like "a," or "the," which affects the flow. HOWEVER, I think this can be advantageous. Your MC is a lab experiment, yes? And it's quite possible he's not from an English-speaking nation, so, my thoughts are, you could use the fact that your English isn't perfect (but then again, who's is?) to make your character more believable, and I think you could do it more realistically than any of us who do speak English as our native tongue could. A famous author, Chuck Palahniuk, did this with his book Pygmy. He writes the whole book in a sort of broken English, and it worked. The book was/is a New York Times bestseller. So, something to think about. :]

What do you think about that suggestion?

Plot:
I can't really say much about this, other than the wording of this chapter made it much easier to understand, and so far, this seems very original. I like it a lot. Your characters are three-dimensional and the reader wants to know more about them. One thing though. I remember saying something in my last review about the title not exactly fitting. Your sentence works to explain the title meaning, but it does read rather abruptly. For this, I suggest you can make it even better by doing one of these:

1. Change the sentence around. My suggestion: "My life, this conflict...I'd taken to calling it 'Bestial Conflict,'"...then the rest of your sentence.
2. Reveal it later in the story. (I don't really recommend this one.)

I like the current ending, it just needs some tweaking.

Overall:
I really like this, and it's much improved from the last chapter. I think it's great that you're writing in English, and I think this story is going to be great. :)
*Clicks like, follow, and submit*

Keep on writing! Also, let me know when chapter 2 is up, and if you ever need a review, visit my thread! Or write on my wall. xD I'm not particular.
~Sporky
Grasped by the throat, grasped by the throat. That's how I feel about love. That it's not worth it.

REVIEWS FOR YOU | | Uprising (coming soon!)
  





User avatar
213 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 15813
Reviews: 213
Fri Sep 03, 2010 7:04 pm
SporkPunk says...



I got your message so I toddled on over here to check it out. Sooo....

Yes, the ending is great! I really like it. Good job in the revision, Kyou! :]

~Spork
Grasped by the throat, grasped by the throat. That's how I feel about love. That it's not worth it.

REVIEWS FOR YOU | | Uprising (coming soon!)
  





User avatar
446 Reviews



Gender: None specified
Points: 28776
Reviews: 446
Sat Sep 04, 2010 2:09 pm
Yuriiko says...



Hello there Kyou!

Here as requested. :3

Nitpicks and suggestions in RED.


Selfishly I knew she could have the information I needed, aninformation that could be a bridge for me between death and life.


I think you wouldn't need to repeat that word anymore, so perhaps change that to "which could be a bridge...". Anyways, that's just a suggestion.

While thinking I finished bandaging her, afterwards making sure I did the best I could for her.


That colored phrase sounds awkward to read, so you might want to rephrase that.

I crouched and took off a PDA out of her vest just to crush it to leave no tracks behind.


I remember this, haha. So this is maybe just me but I would like to suggest that you write it like this:" I crouched and took out a PDA from her vest and crushed it to leave no tracks behind."

while I was looking in her eyes,


"Closed eyes", you mean?

Confident in my abilities I pat her head, smiling like if I found a friend.


Past tense: "patted". ;)

I couldn’t help but to smile, thinking to myself that maybe, maybe I found a good reason to struggle for another day of my stressful life.


Awesome line. :3

Though back then I didn't have even a slightest idea of how complex would my struggle become.


A bit awkward to read again though I understand what you are really trying to say here, but it would have taken me to read this twice. A suggestion: "Though back then I didn't even have the slightest idea of how complex my struggle would have been." <<-- I'm not sure with that though, just probably it doesn't seem to sound right in what you have done of that specific line.

A conflict of mortality gained on strength, becoming a personal war I later named 'Bestial conflict' as only a beast could get so far, nothing else.


A good final line.


~

Kicking aside those nitpicks, I thank you for the good read. Well done for some of your impressive paragraphs and lines. However, you might just want to add more spice here. It's not that this is cliche' but the tone of your character seems a bit dark, in not a good way I think. It's just probably me, I don't know, haha.

Anyways, you have improved a lot and considering that English is not your first language, this improvised chapter is really good. Your punctuations are getting much better and the realistic quality here in your piece is pretty obvious and almost flawless. But you might want to look out for your verbs too, there are just some tiny little errors I have seen so far. Also, the plot itself is really good, I can't wait to read what comes after this. And watch out too when it comes to your wording or how you sometimes narrate things, because there are just some awkward sentences that pops out suddenly, which makes me to pause and really comprehend of what you really are trying to say or describe something. So that's it for now, Kyou. All in all, this is pretty good. Hope I helped and PM me for any questions.

Keep writing!

Peace out! :smt004

~yuri
"Life is a poem keep it in the present tense." -Sherrel Wigal
  





User avatar
411 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 42428
Reviews: 411
Sun Sep 05, 2010 1:04 pm
BenFranks says...



Hey there Kyousuke, here as requested. Sorry you've been waiting for this review a while, but I hope it helps all the same. My suggestions, comments and improvements will be in red.

Kyousuke wrote:Chapter 1 - Conflict

“Hang in there, you’ve still got a purpose to serve.” I personally think "there" sounds better than "here". Those words subconsciously escaped my selfish lips as I was firmly bandaging one woman’s bullet wounds. Her Spec Ops clothes were getting soaked in blood so quick I was afraid I’d that I wouldn't not stop her bleeding in time. I think by using the phrase instead of "I'd" allows the reader to dwell on the situation for longer and feel the effect of your writing more. Leaning against a dirty wall of a room located in one of many buildings, she looked like her soul was stuck between real world and what comes after. Her dark eyes were distant, her expression tearful. I like that comparison and image.

She didn’t even twitch after hearing my words, one would think she had already bled out, though that still wasn’t the case I still knew that wasn't true. (I suggest this because 'case' is too formal and because you're writing in first person, using words like 'knew' or 'think' help create a more secure atmosphere) Those distant eyes still sparkled faintly with life, her breathing – even shallow – was still present. All I could think of was that she was deep in her thoughts, collecting shattered memories of past. I was a witness to what happened. , so I had slight idea of what she might have thought. (If you get rid of that line you keep more of the feeling that your character is there. You don't need to explain how or why your character thinks they know what they're thinking it just disrupts the fluency in my opinion.)

I watched her group for hours from distance, aware of their origin and possible goal. A sunny day of late summer was a last day for her group of four people after entering the building, where three of them realized their limits with the last exhale. I knew as their Spec Ops clothes were easy to notice among many bodies along the way to the room. Your story has jumped in this paragraph and I've completely lost where your character has gone. Is he one the way to the room? Or is he still attending to the woman bleeding out? Are the Spec-Ops team now dead? I'm really confused and I think you need to fix the clarity somehow.

Maybe it was for the better that they'd died, because otherwise I could be the cause of their death, but I was seriously desperate to save that woman. Careful with tenses. Selfishly I knew she could have information I needed, an information that could be a bridge for me between death and life. After all, everything I did was just for me as I had nobody else than myself to care for.

“Life, eh,” I sighed, reminding myself my own life - a life of lab rat on run. Dialogue followed by periods should end the sentence, where as if you use "I said" or in this case, "I sighed", you need to be using a comma. Finding out truth was a painful turning point, which eventually led me all the way to being a highly ‘wanted criminal’ as my sins were of an unusual kind. My body carried human kind’s achievement many thought was impossible, so it made sense that when I escaped grasp and control of people, who ordered expensive lab experiment, they were desperate to find me, to get their result back. Careful over clarity and sentence length because it's growing mildly confusing again. You need to stop jumping from one place to another. If your character is still attending to the wounded woman, why talk about morality, history and all this? Shouldn't it be discovered as we go along? Don't spill it all out in the first chapter because it's putting your story's fluency at risk.

While thinking I finished bandaging her, afterwards making sure I did the best I could for her. Aware of her blood loss I took a small box out of a pocket of my baggy shorts to open it and put a few sugar dices in her mouth. Even though it was a small amount, it was still a boost for her blood regeneration.

Behind strokes of her dark brown hair I saw her eyes looking straight at me, looking as if she was expecting death to come from my hands.
“Drop that look, it won’t change a thing. There’s no way I’d kill you after all the effort. Besides, officially you’re already dead.”

I saw her try to speak, but not even one word got through her twitching lips. She lost a lot of blood, pain made her numb.
“You see, by now your status should be already would already be KIA. (Just a bit clearer and less wooden) You were sent here for something and I’m sure they never truly expected you or your team to come back. All they really needed was information, isn’t that right?”

Her eyes dropped, signing me that I hit the spot. I crouched and took off a PDA out of her vest just to crush it to leave no tracks behind. I knew I had to carry her somewhere safe, but I was aware that there were still a lot of people around greedy for our lives. I felt pity rise deep inside of me while I was looking in her eyes, imagining a poor soul thrown away by a government, which saw soldiers like pawns.

Confident in my abilities I pat her head, smiling like as if I found a friend. Her bleeding stopped, making me feel even happier. I like the idea of the character here, makes them see mildly psychotic.
“Not everybody gets a second chance at life, savor it.”

I stood up and headed through all the garbage to the door, holding a silver Colt 1991 in my hand. Killing was my specialty, an art; I was the best at after being a lab experiment for years. Careful of missing punctuation, concentrate on keeping a confident flow. I couldn’t help but to smile, thinking to myself that maybe, just maybe I found a good reason to struggle for another day of my stressful life.

Though back then I didn't have even have the a slightest idea of how complex would my struggle become. A conflict of mortality gained on strength, becoming a personal war I later named 'Bestial conflict' as only a beast could get so far, nothing else.


Okay, so I enjoyed the characters and the way they progressed over the storyline. I think the main targets you have to focus on are your fluency and the way you plot-jump in your story because sometimes I found myself quite lost and the story very hard to follow.

I hope this helped,
~Ben
  





User avatar
565 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 1395
Reviews: 565
Mon Sep 06, 2010 8:20 pm
Stori says...



after all the effort.


"All that effort"; don't worry so much about it though.
  





User avatar
91 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 12142
Reviews: 91
Tue Sep 07, 2010 5:44 am
Wolferion says...



My sincere thanks to everybody who reviewed =) A lot of grammar mistakes and misunderstood meanings, though now I know what's wrong and I'll look into it. Thank you once again!

Have a nice day,
Kyou
~Don't beg for things, do it yourself or else you'll never get anything~
-Formerly Shinda
  








You can't blame the writer for what the characters say.
— Truman Capote