z

Young Writers Society


Battle Of The Hopeless (Chapter 2)



User avatar
80 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 333
Reviews: 80
Thu Oct 06, 2011 6:32 pm
polinkacreations says...



Spoiler! :
This has also been published before, but it is polished up and re-edited now, so hopefully way better than before:D Enjoy!


Felix

I have always wondered what the outside world feels like now. How I wish to feel the touch of grass, or rain streaming down my face, the ground under my feet, or see the deep, blue sky above me... All these things I have taken for granted.
Oh, how I wish to feel alive again.

Today is exactly one year, six months and two weeks that I’ve been in a coma.

I can feel everything around me, I can hear everything, but I cannot see, and cannot move, however much I wish to. Sometimes, when the nurses come in the morning, I concentrate ever so hard to move a single finger, just one movement, then they would know I still had hope, that I was still alive... but all my attempts have failed.

I don’t remember how I fell into a coma. Was it a disease, or an accident, I cannot remember... even if I tried, so many times, every single day I want to remember something new, but all I have is faded, jagged memories, all mixed up in my mind, like a puzzle I can’t put together right. Emotions have also faded, as if washed out. All I can do is bring back old memories, the scarce remains of my life, to remember what colours look like, what texture feels like. And, every day, those feelings become blunt, unrecognisable, strange...
I often think of the summer before my coma. I was swaying back and forth on swings attached to a huge, brownish-grey branch of the nearby maple tree. As I pushed from the ground and flew forward and high up, I could see the horizon, and below it, the vast fields. I wonder if the swings are still there. I wonder if the wheat still gently rocks from side to side, and if it still looks like a golden sea, quavering below my feet....
***

I woke with the sun shedding its light on me... about three quarters down my arm, so it must have been around eleven o’clock. I heard the nurse open the window, and so the cool breeze flew over my lifeless body. She told her friend to get something, and stepped closer to me.

It was the daily routine again - she turned on the machine that supplies me with food, and wiped my face with a damp towel. She did this very gently, I could hear her calm breathing, and feel her steady hand wipe away the dust from my bony face. But today, the nurse was different. Her perfume isn’t sweet like the one who usually greets me in the morning, it is a rather strong and flowery smell. I hated it. I could feel her long hair rubbing against my arm, and for a second I wished I would get goosebumps, because it tickled me, but still, nothing. It’s always nothing. I don’t even know, how for a year and a half, I still managed to have hope. I guess I’m much like my father - I never lost hope, and never had anything other than my way.

But to say the truth, I was rather desperate. I could feel my body, every inch of it, but unable to move it. I felt helpless and trapped. I was sick of the tubes sticking out of me, my numb body, my lifeless arms, my constant anger and anxiety bursting out, silently.

Sometimes, I wished I had just died. I thought it was better than the state I was in. I wished for death and prayed to the gods to let me go, but eventually, it all came back to blank tiredness, and the day dragged on.

I have been trying to know about everything that’s going on around me, and from noises and voices in the room, I could picture my surroundings quite clearly: white-washed walls, a bed - with me on it, a table and a chair, a wooden door that made a loud noise every time it was opened, but I didn’t know what the floor was, as the nurses never wore heels or platformed shoes. It was probably tiled, and white as well. There were two windows, which opened so that the wind would always blow over me. And there were two nurses, usually. One had a hoarse voice but a smooth touch, and the other spoke very loudly, and did everything fast, as if she was always in a rush for something. I wished I could be in a rush to do something. But all my days passed calmly and slowly, and all I could do is attempt to entertain myself. I did this by either imaging where I was, the appearance of the nurses, or I would often try to find out what was going on in the world, in the world where I no longer play a part.

Thankfully, this wasn’t too hard, because the nurses were very chatty and I could always hear them from the room next to mine. I knew there was a conflict, which might very soon evolve into war. And that it was going to be a big one, and that humans were probably not going to win it. I tried to figure out the reason why, because the nurses didn’t know it themselves. The closest that they, and I, ever got to an answer when a doctor mentioned the spirits. The thought kept me occupied since, because my father still is (if he isn’t dead, of which I am not sure), a specialist on the spirits. He studied them from university, and had a career in trying to understand how they lived, worked, and fitted in with us. Still, I could not understand. Why would the spirits cause a war? As far as I knew, the spirits were the calmest, pure and understanding creatures who have ever lived on this earth. What would the humans have to do to anger them so much? The nurses discussed this quite often, but never got close to an answer. Also, they never sounded worried or anxious, even though a war was happening, which was very confusing for me. After all, I had no idea where I was...

The questions kept rolling in, and as soon as I thought of answers, new questions evolved, and I soon found myself stuck in my own prejudice and assumptions, purely based on my father’s words, and the nurse’s gossip. It angered me, so much that I knew I couldn’t hold back any longer.

Today, I have decided I cannot stay the way I am anymore. Today, I decided I would escape.

As soon as the thought flashed through my mind, it carried hope and determination, even though I had no idea if my plan was to work. But to me, everything seemed possible. I just
had to get out of here, out of my lifeless body, out of this hospital, away from food through a tube, away from smells of hospital and strong perfume, away from the noises of laughter which felt like thorns wrapped around my heart. I tried to calm myself down, and concentrate. I thought out my plan carefully. In the first three months of my coma, my father would come and sit next to me. He would talk to me, even if everyone kept telling me I was practically dead.
‘‘Son, you can escape this. You can do it. I did.’’

At first, I didn’t believe him - I had hope that I would awaken, the thought of being in a coma forever... never even came to mind. I thought that medicine is advanced enough, people fall into comas and then awaken... but that never happened. Soon enough, I tried to face the thought that I am destined to die twice. But, I still don’t believe this.
I don’t want to. It never brought anything but depression, and even more anger. I don’t believe this and I never will.

Because today, I decided I was going to leave this world.

It was a win-win situation - I have nothing to lose, and if I die, I do not care.
And so, I calmed myself down, and thought of nothing.
Just white space, oblivion.
Of course, it was hard at first, but I still had what seemed like an eternity to practice...
Everything was becoming blank, I had blocked out all the noise, voices, and just escaped the world, trying to also exclude all my emotions, and try to feel...

Nothing... no pain, no anger... no frustration or broken memories... no helpless attempts to be alive again... just nothing... peace... a sudden feeling of warmth... something that words cannot even describe, such a wonderful feeling... something I have been waiting for ... so... long...
"Be who you are and say what you feel, because those who mind don't matter and those who matter don't mind." - Dr. Seuss
  





User avatar
24 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 1620
Reviews: 24
Mon Oct 10, 2011 4:58 pm
View Likes
smilelikeyoumeanit says...



Hey me again :) I'm reviewing the second chapter now :)

Today is exactly one year, six months and two weeks that I’ve been in a coma.

- i like the fact that this line simply tells you what the point of the chapter is. I think this is what chapter 1 is lacking a bit.

Today, I decided I would escape.

- I love them way this sentence changes the mood of this novel.

Overall i prefer this chapter to the last, the character in this chapter is easier to relate to and i am taking it that they are two different characters Keep writing and post on my wall when you are down chapter 3 because i am really enjoying reading your work :)
  





User avatar
233 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 9739
Reviews: 233
Thu Oct 13, 2011 4:44 pm
View Likes
Chirantha says...



Hi there Polink,

Well, I'm here to review the 2nd chapter. Hopefully, I'll be able to review it before I have to sleep.

Alright, this was a great chapter and I will tell you why I found it great after I point out the mistakes. So, on with the review.

Mistakes

I want to remember something new, but all I have is faded, jagged memories, all mixed up in my mind, like a puzzle I can't put together right.

"All I have were faded, jagged memories"

and from noises and voices in the room,

From "the" noises and voices in the room.

And that it was going to be a big one, and that humans were probably not going to win it.

Don't use "and" much. Repetition is never a good thing to do in stories, unless you are trying to emphasize something. So, change this sentence into something like, "It sounded like it was going to be a big one, and that the humans were probably not going to win it."

The closest that they, and I, ever got to an answer was when a doctor mentioned the spirits.


He would talk to me, even if everyone kept telling me I was practically dead.

I think you meant, "even if everyone kept telling him that I was practically dead."

Plot

I'm not sure how this character enter into the plot but I'm so impressed by this chapter. The reason is because you portrayed the feelings of a man in a coma as perfectly as anyone can. Also, emotionally, you made us feel the man's frustration, pain and sorrow as if they were our own feelings. So, whatever the reason you included this character maybe, I'm really glad you wrote this chapter, because unlike the last chapter, your writing skills seemed profoundly adapted to suit this kind of situation and explain it perfectly through the use of intricately detailed sentences. Well done.

I won't comment on the plot as I have no idea how this man connects to the main plot. But I do have a hunch. ;)

Descriptions

Perfect descriptions results in a perfectly established connection between the reader and the story. Your descriptions were great in showing the exact environment he's in. The setting at that time. The actions of the non-important characters. You have included every tiny detail that might help the readers to immerse themselves in the story. So, well done on the descriptions, and I hope you continue with it.

Character Descriptions

For some reason, I have some trouble imagining the main character. I can imagine a patient with tubes going in and out of the body, but I cannot make a clear picture of him in my mind. One of the reasons for this is the fact that you've not given any hint about the his age, nor about his facial appearance. Not that it would matter as he becomes a spirit at the end of the chapter. But from the start till the end, a tiny bit about the character's appearance would've done this chapter some good.

You had taken emotional development to an upper level with this chapter. The way you had replicated the exact feelings of a man who cannot experience the world as we know it. The feelings seem extremely realistic and I congratulate you on that.

Title

I can see how the title is well applied to this. It seems to speak of the exact story of this chapter. So, well done on the title.

Overall, it was a good chapter and I enjoyed reading it.

Good luck and I hope to read the next chapters as well. :D

- C -
Warden: "If you want to lead, all you have to do is ask."
Alistair: "What? Lead? Me? No, no, no. No leading. Bad things happen when I lead. We get lost, people die, and the next thing you know I'm stranded somewhere without any pants."
- Dragon Age

Need a review?
  





User avatar
541 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 370
Reviews: 541
Wed Nov 02, 2011 2:08 am
View Likes
Lauren2010 says...



Hey polinka! Here again, as requested!

I really, really enjoyed this chapter. The voice of Felix is so natural and believable, it kept me interested and entertained throughout the chapter. Taking him from the viewpoint of someone in a coma is really interesting as well, and you've done such a good job of it.

I am wonder, though, how well this fits in with the chapter before it. This chapter talks of war, so I'm assuming that it's the same war being experienced in the first chapter? But the first chapter talks about fighting holograms, and this about fighting spirits. So which is it? And why do the holograms/spirits want to fight a war with the humans? Or is it the humans fighting a war against the holograms/spirits?

It's okay to skirt around really answering these questions in the first chapter, but carrying this same vague non-telling through the entirety of the second chapter can begin to get frustrating. You don't need to (and shouldn't) reveal everything at once, but the reader needs a little more to go on. They need to know a bit more of what the story is about.

I think if you just explain a little more about this war, what the reasoning behind it is, how its affecting the world, then you'll be golden. You'd have a great opportunity to introduce that information in a subtle way in this chapter simply by having someone visiting Felix (his father, the nurses, doctors, etc) talk more about the specifics. That way, the reader has a bit more to go off of to help them understand what is going on and what is affecting the world that the characters are living in.

Other than that, this was a great chapter! I didn't catch any big grammar issues, and the plot, characters, etc all look completely lovely to me in this chapter. Great job!

Keep writing!

-Lauren-
Got YWS?
  





User avatar
202 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 10840
Reviews: 202
Sat Nov 05, 2011 4:40 pm
View Likes
Blues says...



Hi Polinka!
Here as requested again!

The good bits
Again, your first lines. You instantly hooked me again. I now instantly have so much sympathy for Felix because his situation must be one really hard one.

You portrayed Felix's feelings so well. Instantly, I feel so sorry for him and I desperately hope Felix comes out alive. Everything you said made him seem real and as if YOU were in that situation and survived and knew how it felt. The emotions in this were brilliant. I'm hoping we see some more of Felix and his memories, so many questions arose in my head.

Overall, this chapter was very, very good!

The bits that need improving
you wrote:As soon as the thought flashed through my mind, it carried hope and determination, even though I had no idea if my plan was to work. But to me, everything seemed possible. I just

had to get out of here, out of my lifeless body, out of this hospital, away from food through a tube


These needs to be one paragraph.

Plot-wise, I really wonder where this is going like everyone else, but this is the first chapter from Felix's PoV so you have to stir questions for him. We're now hooked so we'll need answers :)

You also wrote:Today is exactly one year, six months and two weeks that I’ve been in a coma.


I don't know, but how would Felix be able to tell? Because he is technically guessing. Unless you make that clearer that he's guessing... here also:

You wrote:I woke with the sun shedding its light on me... about three quarters down my arm, so it must have been around eleven o’clock.

Again, how would he tell? I think you mean he can feel it, but that would also need to be made clearer. I was a little confused and was thinking "Did she switch narrators? Is he now omniscient?"

Overall

This was an excellent chapter, Polinka! I really enjoyed the way you wrote, the emotion, everything. None of the suggestions affected what I thought of the chapter. It was great!

I'll be off to your third chapter soon.

Keep Writing!
Mac
  





User avatar
167 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 7459
Reviews: 167
Fri Dec 09, 2011 5:32 am
View Likes
confetti says...



My dear, I am so sorry for how long it's taken me to get to this. And so, thanks a million for the patience. It's been a long week. So, without further ado, here is your review. I hope you enjoy me picking your story to bits.

I have always wondered what the outside world feels like now.

Not a great way to start of your chapter. Not only is it incorrect in the grammatical sense, but it's also an awkward read. A suggestion - "I've begun to forget what the outside world feels like." Sounds a bit better, doesn't it?
... All these things I have taken for granted.

This is another sentence that's lacking. To begin, I'm not a fan of using ellipsis's in stories, they have a childish feel to them. I'm not sure how other people feel, but that's what I think of when I look at them. Secondly, it's awkwardly written again. I'm not really sure how to fix it, I might even suggest taking it out entirely unless you can find a way to make it mend.
Oh, how I wish to feel alive again.

This is good, but not good enough. This has the same "oh how I smell the lovely flowers in the morning" feel to it, the type of image with light colours and slight grins. But that's not what you're aiming for, is it? This chapter should be more full of sorrow and hopelessness. Make me feel sorry for this character. I want to, but I'm not quite there.
Today is exactly one year, six months and two weeks that I’ve been in a coma.

I love this, but I feel like it's in a bad spot. You see, you have two sentences on their own in a row. Because of that, you lose the effectiveness you were going for (or at least, I assume you were). I would suggest picking the one that you want to be the most prominent and leaving it alone, and with the other, attach it to another paragraph. Honestly, this would make a wonderful first line to this chapter (certainly much better than the one you have now). Just some food for thought.
Sometimes, when the nurses come in the morning, I concentrate ever so hard to move a single finger, just one movement, then they would know I still had hope, that I was still alive... but all my attempts have failed.

This sentence is too long and full of commas - break it into two. Also, you change tenses. In the last chapter, you used past tense (for the most part), but you're using present tense here. Unless there's a reason (though I can't think of a good one), you need to keep your story in the same tense. I find that you're best at keeping a consistent present tense, so I would aim for that. But, I haven't looked at the other chapters yet, so if they're all in past tense, I apologize.
Was it a disease, or an accident, I cannot remember... even if I tried *even though I've tried* ?, so many times, every single day(period here) I want to remember something new, but all I have is faded, jagged memories, all mixed up in my mind, like a puzzle I can’t put together right.

I personally think the bolded bit could go. And by go, I mean highlight it and click that delete button because this sentence is practically begging for that. It just sounds much too awkward and has much too little of a point. As a side note - if he can remember the exact days, why does he have a problem remembering the basic idea of why he's having to count those days? Seems a bit off. It's understandable if he doesn't know the details, but he should have a basic idea at the very least.
All I can do is bring back old memories, the scarce remains of my life, to remember what colours look like, what texture feels like.

You do this a lot. "All I can do, All I can remember, All I can say, All I can think." Quit it. A couple times is enough. Mixing up your sentence structures would do you some good.
And, every day, those feelings become blunt, unrecognisable, strange...

If his emotions are blunt, it's likely that your story will become blunt. Be careful with this.
I was swaying back and forth on swings attached to a huge, brownish-grey branch of the nearby maple tree.

Well then. Honestly, you don't need that many adjectives. It's not important that the tree was brownish-grey, not at all.

And, every day, those feelings become blunt, unrecognisable, strange...

and
I wonder if the wheat still gently rocks from side to side, and if it still looks like a golden sea, quavering below my feet....

Two ends to two different paragraphs, one after the other. Sloppy.
I woke with the sun shedding its light on me...

Alright, you've begun to use past tense again, so maybe you should stick with this. Just, please, pick one and be consistent. I'm not going to point it out in next chapters, so I hope that you can go through and spot it. Also, the dots are killing me, you've overusing them.
about three quarters down my arm, so it must have been around eleven o’clock.

Nah. Just nah. This is too unrealistic, there's no way that he'll feel that heat so strongly that he can tell it's 3/4 down his arm.
She did this very gently,(period or semi-colon) I could hear her calm breathing, and feel her steady hand wipe away the dust from my bony face.

But today, the nurse was different. Her perfume isn’t sweet like the one who usually greets me in the morning, it is a rather strong and flowery smell.

Another change in tense. Try something like "But that day" instead of "But today," it might help you to stick with the tense. As well, it would be neat to see a strong reaction from him. Maybe it reminds him of a memory that's painful, or a memory that's happy but makes him miss home.
I could feel my body, every inch of it, but unable to move it.

You repeat yourself a lot throughout the story. Ranting is a thing I've noticed you do much too often. I want to see some action. It's tricky to do when your main character is in a coma, but there are ways. He could overhear some dialogue in the room, or he could be thinking of a memory.
Thankfully, this wasn’t too hard, because the nurses were very chatty and I could always hear them from the room next to mine.

This is what I'm talking about - dialogue to balance out the rants. But you don't give any, and that's the problem. Show us that they're chatty, don't tell us.
I knew there was a conflict, which might very soon evolve into war. And that it was going to be a big one, and that humans were probably not going to win it.

I can see that this connect with the previous chapter, which is exciting, but I would much rather see it in dialogue.
After all, I had no idea where I was...

AGH.
I just

had to get out of here,

Connect these
I had hope that I would awaken, the thought of being in a coma forever... never even came to mind.

Pulling my hair out by the roots
and then awaken... but that never happened.

...

And that's about it for nitpicks. I'm going to go ahead and point out the main issues that I think need resolving here.

Uno:
I realize that near the beginning you said he's given up on emotions. Still, I want to see some more emotion in this. This wasn't exactly your biggest issue, but I still felt disconnected from him.

Dos:
The writing can definitely be tweaked. It's still a bit weak and could use some more description and flare. Something you do a lot is write run-on sentences and making them with heaps of commas. You're not fooling anybody - break up those sentences or thin them out.

Tres:
You often change tenses and it's the most distracting part of your story. This is something that can't be ignored, you should really go through the chapters and change this. As I've said, pick one and stick to it.

Cuatro:
You rant too much. This entire story begins to feel like one giant rant. You need more action, more dialogue. For every time he's talking about the nurses talking, change it to dialogue. Make them actually talk. I love the idea you have going on right now, it's downright awesome, but you're not executing it properly. I know you can do it, so do it.

Again, thanks for the patience with the review, I feel that this made up for it a bit. Adios
"So the writer who breeds more words than he needs, is making a chore for the reader who reads."
— Dr. Seuss
  








i, too, use desk chairs for harm and harm alone
— Omni